RESTAURANT REVIEW: Gate House Cafe
By James Leach on Mar. 19th, 2008
I ordered the mini burgers at Village Gate's new Gate House Café, expecting that what would come out would be some variation on the sliders - tiny beef patties on cute little rolls - that have been on trendy restaurant menus for the past couple of years. What arrived at our table was a precariously
balanced tower of meat and potatoes: a bed of shoestring fries topped with three thick burgers stacked one atop the other and held together with cheddar cheese, smothered in meat hot sauce, and then sprinkled with chunks of beer-battered onion rings. In short, it was a garbage plate, and a pretty good one at that.
The menu at the Gate House is, in part, an homage to all things Rochester. In addition to Chef Kristen Flores-Fratto's reinterpretation of a garbage plate, you'll find Zweigle's white hots (albeit baked in puff pastry and served atop a spicy mustard sauce), chicken wings, and an entire menu named after various landmarks and personalities in the Rochester area. You will also find some of the best burgers and pizzas available in the Rochester area served in an atmosphere that evokes the mod architecture of 1960's California restaurants and lounges, right down to the dark wood accents, the funky earth tones, and the geometric light fixtures. The wait staff even wears retro-styled shirts with the name of the restaurant emblazoned on the pocket.
The emphasis at the Gate House is on pizza and burgers, but the appetizers deserve some attention, too. Although the burgers in the "mini burgers" ($9) dish were slightly more done than I would have liked them, the overall juiciness of the meat sauce (a traditional Rochester hot sauce made with a bit of cinnamon and a hit of chili powder), and the delectable greasy bite of the cheese went a long way toward reinvigorating the meat - and providing a tasty sop for the fries underneath it all. Likewise, the Zweigle white hots in puff pastry ($7) were both familiar and novel. All of the elements of the traditional white hot - bread, mustard, onions - are there, but served in a way that elevates the dish into something closer to a cocktail canapé than a quick lunch. The hots are baked in the pastry, cut into sections, served atop a pool of creamy, rich mustard sauce and garnished with sweet onions. The wings were sadly not as good as the traditional fried Buffalo wing ($7). Roasted in the wood oven and dressed with garlic, rosemary, thyme and other herbs, the skin on the wings was rubbery rather than crisp, and the meat itself had a disagreeable gamey flavor that lingered on my tongue.
Two other appetizers, the bruschetta pomodoro ($6), and the Mediterranean plate ($7), were better than the wings. The bruschetta combined surprisingly sweet and ripe-tasting fresh tomatoes, basil, and garlic atop rounds of baguette for a solid introduction to the meal. The Mediterranean sampler featured two crispy and fine-grained falafel patties, a dollop of smooth and garlicky hummus, and a small assortment of marinated grilled vegetables, all of which were quite good. The tabouli, however, was sour, dense, and tasted as if it had been sitting around for a very long time.
The appetizers were a bit uneven, but the pizzas and burgers were spot on. Chef Flores-Fratto brought her extensive knowledge of Italian food and wood-oven cooking to bear on her recipe for a true Neapolitan pizza, achieving a pie that is a very close rival to the best pizzas to be found in New York City ($10-$11). Her pizza starts with a crust that is substantial without being too bready - easily folded in half with just the tiniest bit of sag at the tip. The crust has just enough crunch to be satisfying to chew, but it does not overwhelm the toppings. She uses a very simple, subtly sweet and acidic tomato sauce as the understory for a rich variety of ingredients, including the usual suspects plus prosciutto, artichokes, smoked mozzarella, chorizo, caramelized onions, hummus and goat cheese in several wonderful and very satisfying combinations. My only complaint was with her RPO, a white pizza topped with roasted peppers, feta, parsley, mozzarella, canned black olives, and a staggering quantity of apparently raw garlic. I love garlic, but this was too much even for me. I was grateful that I had her Liberty Pole pizza - a seductive combination of prosciutto, artichokes, and smoked mozzarella - to turn to for solace.
Flores-Fratto's partner and husband, Michael Corson, grew up around burgers - his family owned the Bedrock Charbroil in Fairport - and he considers himself something of an authority on the subject. After tasting his heart-stoppingly good burgers ($6-$10), I'm willing to concede that he's truly a master of the craft. Made with ground chuck (or Wagu beef - a silly affectation in my opinion, add $5), Corson's burgers are started on the restaurant's char grill and then finished on the flattop, developing a smoky goodness and a fine char on the outside while retaining most of their succulent juices within. Cooked to a perfect medium rare, and topped with bacon, bleu cheese, and pesto mayonnaise, the juice from this wonderful burger ran down my fingers, pooled on the plate, and made a delicious condiment for the fries that accompanied it.
For a restaurant that has been open for less than a month, the Gate House Café is doing remarkably well. The service staff is knowledgeable and helpful, very welcoming to families, and willing to accommodate even the oddest requests (when I could not carry both my 3-year-old dining companion and my pizzas out to my car, they were more than happy to send someone along with me). All in all, if Flores-Fratto and Corson stick to what they do best - their pizzas and burgers, respectively - the Gate House will make a fine and long-lasting addition to the neighborhood.
Gate House Cafe
Inside Village Gate, 274 N Goodman St.
473-2090
Monday-Wednesday, 11:30 a.m.-10 p.m.; Thursday-Saturday, 11:30 a.m.-11 p.m.










User Comments
Here is what others say about this article. City Newspaper isn't responsible for the content of comments.
Michael A. Ciarico on March 23rd, 2008
Did James Leach take his meals to go from the Gate House along with a couple 3 year olds? Im a little confused. Did he not stay and eat at the Gate House? Did he bring two 3 year olds with him to review a new restaurant?
How can he focus on fairly reviewing this great new place. Im pretty sure their target customer is not a father and his 3 year old's. I would suspect that James had to be a little distracted unless his kids were staped to their chairs and gagged. Ive seen 3 year olds in retaurants and i have walked out of places dut to their behavior.
I went to the Gate House on Friday night 3/21. I loved it. It was so nice to see something new and busy in the area. It seems to complete the food court theme to The Village Gate.
I dont know the owners, but it looks like this new spot cost a few bucks. I think James should have went alone or with an adult to rate his experience. This review should be pulled and an apology should be given to the Gate House along with a new review and a cover retarction.
We need more business downtown period, If your going to review a restaurant do it right, leave your kids at home.
Lynn on March 27th, 2008
Maybe Michael should reread the article before getting all worked up...overall it was a good review that made me want to try the place. Obviously the grammar was to complicated for the previous poster, since he was not able to understand that James was trying to carry pizza and 1 child, thus the use of the word "both". And how rude to imply that people shouldn't take their kids out to eat because it might disturb another diner.
Maybe he should be the one getting takeout.
Andrew Wadoski on March 28th, 2008
I take issue with this review for reasons far different from Mr. Ciarico. I ate at the Gatehouse on 3/4 and had one of the worst restauraunt experiences of my life; the food was miserable and the service was poor. Having worked in a range of restaurants as a cook, waiter, dishwasher, host, etc. since my late teens, I am comfortable saying that there was no excuse for anything about that meal. Limpid, greasy wings (the wood oven probably not hot enough); pre-frozen, Macdonalds style fries advertised as homecut; stale bun on my burger; the list goes on. The waitstaff was inattentive and had no apparent knowledge of the food they were serving
mike ciarico on March 28th, 2008
Lynn
What i said was if you are going to review a restaurant you should be completely focused on what your doing. A 3 year old is a distraction. I dont bring a cild with me when i go to work and either should a restaurant reviewer.
To start a business takes alot of Balls, for someone to knock it unfairly is crap. I understood his review fine. Seems like he was a little bitchy for no reason.
As far as being rude, people with 3 year olds, or any children need to get control over them. I dont have to tolerate anyones child. Its been my experiance that most children in public are an embarrassment.
A restaurant reviewer should not be getting takeout, period. And the gate house is no place for children, go to mc donalds if you have kids,
Alex on April 6th, 2008
My experiences at the Gate House on 3/28 was likewise awful. Does this place specifically advertise to people with 3-year-olds in tow? I I really wanted to have dinner with screaming, obnoxious kids, I would eat at Chuck E. Cheese! As if that wasn't bad enough, the din from all the 20-somethings getting tanked on beer at the bar mad the experience even worse.
I had a burger, ordered medium, and it came rare. It wasn't very tasty, either. The meat sauce on top was greasy and bland. My companion's pizza was skimpy and overcooked. For almost $40, we got food no better than we would've at Burger King, and had to suffer through the screams of poorly supervised children.
I can't imagine that the reviewer and I were at the same restaurant. I would suggest that if the owners of this dive can't make better food with a better atmosphere, they should consider making the bar an ordering counter (like at Mc Donalds), and just turning it into the cheap fast-food place that the food they make resembles. Even pretentious Rochesterians should know that this place is an over-priced Don-and-Bob's, not a "trendy" restaurant.
Katie on April 11th, 2008
Having just moved up to Rochester from NYC, I was very excited to see that there was a gourmet burger place opening up, we went and tried the Gatehouse restaurant on March 10, and it did not live up to our expectations at all. I applaud the intentions of the restaurant, and I believe that it could be a hit, however it was a shock to get a burger that was a pre-formed patty dripping with grease for $14! If I had wanted such a burger I would've bought a box of bubba burgers.Additionally, the service was subpar, we spent a lot of time waiting. I really wish Gatehouse the best because I think that it is a great idea, however I think they should make sure that their meals live-up to the image they are trying to sell.
Jason on May 14th, 2008
I had dinner at the Gate House just tonight, and I thought the food was great. The burger came to me quickly and was a perfect medium. The wait-staff was friendly, and I was checked on many times to see how things were going without it seeming pressured. Short of being in the back, I fail to see how Kate could say that the burger was pre-fprmed. Just because it was perfectly round means nothing. There are items that will allow you to do this (I own one), and it also helps assure uniformity. I will return there to eat again, and if it doesn't come out the same I will be sure to tell you.
Dave on May 23rd, 2008
Had lunch there with a friend last week. We shared a Hoffman burger and a Kodak pizza. Both were good but not outstanding. The pizza was surprisingly "foldable" for a wood-fired-oven pizza, which often come out of the oven dry and crackerlike. To me that wasn't a bad thing although I could've used a bit of exterior crunch. The burger was fine, juicy but not greasy. The shoestring fries were indeed McDonaldslike but as McDonald's fries are actually pretty good that was a plus too. With tax and no drinks lunch was $22 which is a little pricey for Rochester but not outrageous. Service was efficient and polite.
I should also note that there was a couple there with an infant. Amazingly, it didn't spoil our meal. Then again I don't hate children, as some people obviously do.
Seriously, though, I have read his comments twice and I cannot fathom what Mr. Ciarico is talking about. If anybody seems to have been distracted, it is he, since I don't see any basis for his assertions that Mr. Leach "knock[ed the Gate House] unfairly," or that his review "was a little bitchy." What I would call "a little bitchy" is someone with the attitude that he "do[es]nt have to tolerate anyones child" and that "most children in public are an embarrassment." I'm glad Mr. Ciarico doesn't bring a child (or "cild" as he puts it) when he goes to work. I kind of doubt that he has any to bring, and I'm glad of that.
Lest you think I'm that guy who brings his screaming brat everywhere, and expects everybody else to put up with it, I will readily agree that there are places, includiing some restaurants, where children don't belong, and that there are some children who don't belong in any restaurant. But based on my experience, the Gate House is not such a restaurant, nor does it pretend to be (it does have a kids' menu, after all), and not every 3-year-old is an "embarrassment" in public. I have never met Mr. Leach but I suspect that I would much prefer the company of his 3-year-old at dinner to that of Mr. Ciarico.
Murray on May 23rd, 2008
I went into the village gate today...didnt go the gate house (I went to the bop shop)..but the gate house was really packed so you would think it couldnt be that bad...but then again I didnt go in...just an observation....I think the guy that does not like kids is just trying to be a tough restaurant guy...Im tough when I eat..I dont like kids!!!...Im tough..now pass me a roll!!!!..the kid probably though he looked like gargamel and started crying...relax on the restaurant pretentious-ness mister
Laura on May 28th, 2008
I live in Village Gate area and was very excited to see a new restaurant opening up this winter. I had dinner at the Gate House in March and, along with others who have commented above, was less than impressed. The pizza was burnt and soggy at the same time (how is that even possible?!) and the caesar salad had disgusting pieces of cold, rubbery pasta in it (why?!). I was so disappointed.
Then, last weekend, I was going out with friends who suggested the Gate House for dinner. None of them had been, and they all really wanted to go, so I gritted my teeth and said okay. What a transformation!! It was like a new restaurant. The service was great and the food was too. I had the LIberty Pole pizza, and it was cooked perfectly, just the right mix of salty, crunchy and cheesy.
I guess on my first visit, I experienced some of the growing pains of a new restaurant. So, my advice for those of you who tried the restaurant out early on, give it another chance before passing final judgment. I will definitely be back.