City Blogs: Entertainment Blog

June 24, 2009 at 10:20pm

"So You Think You Can Dance" 2009 Top 16: 10 million viewers looking at her butt

Recommend Blog Post
Total Recommendations (0)

Toni Basil and her AMAZING beret was the guest host. She babbled on for a while about how she was a locking pioneer. I suppose that's true, it just seems weird for this tiny white lady to go on about bringing street dance to the people. But there you have it. Still love her.

The night started out rough with two bum dances, but picked up after that. For the third straight week there weren't three routines I felt deserved being the bottom. So tomorrow should be interesting.

Karla & Jonathan, hip-hop routine by Dave Scott to "By My Side" by Jadakiss. Everything about this was bad. Bad song. Bad choreography. And especially, bad dancing. The two of them were not together AT ALL. I know I say that a lot with hip-hop routines, but these guys were WAY off. They couldn't get the synchronized head bop right! Did they even practice? It was supposed to be a modern-day Bonnie & Clyde thing, and none of that came through at all. There was no attitude. In parts it looked like they were doing two different routines. Simply no chemistry. I think Karla did a moderately better job, but neither of them were any good. Probably the worst routine of the season. Nigel pointed out that there was no excitement in the routine at all. He then actually said "Betcha they're in the Bottom 3!" Ouch.

Asuka & Vitolio, jazz by Mandy Moore to "Heartbreaker" by Pat Benatar. They had me at Benatar. They had me especially at Asuka's costume and make-up. And then they lost me with the unspectacular dancing. Asuka seemed to be holding back. The consensus in my viewing party was that they COULD have dancedthis off the stage, and they didn't. There was a real lack of energy. I mean, they were together for the most part, but I wanted more passion. It's Pat Benatar! It's "Heartbreaker"! It got better once the song went into its breakdown section. There were some good lifts from Vitolio, which seems to be his strong suit. Nigel loved it. This is the second jazz routine in two weeks that I found lacking energy, but that the judges loved it. Thankfully Mary called them out for ultimately not being as good as they can be.

Melissa & Ade, rhumba by Tony Meredith to "Emotion" by Destiny's Child. Melissa's outfit was so skanktacular, I loved it. She was barely wearing any clothes, and her left boob nearly popped out at one point. Much love. The dance itself was certainly sensual; it was a great routine. There was a spectacular move where Melissa did a vertical split and then turned it into a twist. Amazing. I felt Ade was stiff at times, but Melissa was totally entrancing. I had written her off completely when the show started, but she's one to watch. I was even turned on by her. The judges loved it. Nigel and Mary both said that Ade did a great job presenting her. I guess! I just found it hard to pay attention to him when she was bewitching me. Also, Ade: GET RID OF THE PICK!

Janette & Brandon, hip-hop by Dave Scott to "What a World" by Common. The set up was a battle between rock girl and hip-hop guy. They even brought out the chair from the infamous Danny/Neil dueling prince routine a couple seasons back. The routine was super fun and bouncy, and the story came through loud and clear. Janette did spectacularly well, and I loved her look. They hit it just fine -- not as hard as they could, but it was believable. The two of them were perfectly in synch. Brandon pulled out some good tricks toward the end, but this was Janette's routine. The judges loved it.

Kayla & Kupono, Viennese waltz with Jean-Marc to "Sweet Dreams for You" by Jewel. The routine was supposed to be a dream, and it was certainly quite dreamlike. Ethereal. Elegant. Everything a good waltz should be. I thought they were very good, especially for a new couple. Kayla in particular was amazing -- her extensions are just mindbending. I think her carriage was better than his, too. It all felt like one long move, as though it never stopped. Up and down, up and down - I thought it was really flowy and beautiful. Although Kupono is still a little too soft for me, he was a better partner than Max. And Kayla looked stunning. Mary put them on the Hot Tamale Train despite the dance not being a spicy number! This is the THIRD WEEK IN A ROW for Kayla! I love it.

Evan & Randi, contemporary by Mia Michaels to "Koop Isladn Blues" by Koop. The routine was all about Randi's amazing ass, her juicy booty. She looked amazing in the number, like something out of "Chicago." It was more jazzy than contemporary, but I liked it. I feel like Evan got lost in this number a bit. They were perfectly together throughout. Another really sexy number. Mia was worried that it could look cliché; there was nothing cliché about that. It was, as Cat pointed out, cheeky. Love it! The judges loved it. I want Randi's Unitard Girl shirt!

Caitlin & Jason, paso doble with Jean-Marc to "O'Fortuna" from "Carmina Burana." I love the paso doble. It's so fucking dramatic. And this one started out with incredible acrobatics from moment one, with some killer lifts. I loved the outfits. It was like something out of Conan. More shirtless Jason, please. Jason was dancing very strong, if overacting a bit. He was incredibly intense. The routine ran out of steam a bit toward the end, until he practically mounted the woman on the stage. Yumbo. Nigel mentioned that Jason was focusing too much on the audience too much and kind of ignoring his partner. I can see that.

Jeanine & Phillip, Broadway number by Tyce DiOrio to "Moses" from "Singin' in the Rain." They were dressed up all 50's and danced around a loveseat, which at one point Phillip jumped over. That was impressive, but overall, Phillip was kind of lackluster. Jeanine was totally suited for this type of number: her look, her face, everything worked. Up til about halfway through I thought it was the best Tyce number I'd ever seen - it was fun, had some personality. Then the last half of the routine was typical Tyce BS, with people just running around the stage. Should have ended halfway through. But still: WAY better than last week for those two. Nigel was quite Frank with Phillip, telling him he has to step it up. He all but told them they deserved to be in the bottom last week, and that if Phillip doesn't improve, he will be going home, popular or not. I appreciated that.

Predictions: Karla and Jonathan are completely fucked, and deservedly so. That routine was pathetic. I think Asuka and Vitolio are in trouble. It was forgettable and it really lacked punch. The third spot is a toss up. I can see Jason and Caitlin back in the bottom - I don't think they have a fan base for some reason - and I can see Kayla and Kupono there if America is blasé toward Viennese waltz. But ultimately I think Karla and Jonathan are out of here.

Comments for ""So You Think You Can Dance" 2009 Top 16: 10 million viewers looking at her butt" (3)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.

User Photo

Bob said on Jun. 24, 2009 at 10:29pm

Boy, this is a tough season. In my opinion, strongest season ever and it should be. I don't have too much to say about this week. I loved the "Randi Ass" routine and the Waltz.. Jonathan and Karla were the weakest and I do not think either of them can survive another week in the bottom three. I'm a Jon fan, but I gots to be honest! Bye guys. I do not know who the other two bottom will be, but I have a wish list. Brandon/Jenette and Asuka/Vitolio.

Dear Kayla Rodomski,
I am still in your corner, but if you want to be a fashion model we need to talk about your hair again. Sorry babe.
Love, Bob

User Photo

Cathy said on Jun. 25, 2009 at 6:28am

Toni was light years beyond Lil C!! I found that the music chosen for some of the dances had a huge effect on how much I liked the dance. I sort of turned off before they even started dancing.

I thought Vitolio/Asuka danced fairly well. Hated the choreography and am not alone in seeing a chemistry between them. Kupono/Kayla...beautiful. Loved Evan/Randi ( I think they dance well and they are both too adorable). I think Jason/Caitlan are safe but didn't like the dance one bit. Hated: Jeanine/Phillip...she was better than he and that Tyce is more than annoying. I could get abusive with him.

Major danger: Karla/Jonathan

User Photo

Kathy said on Jun. 25, 2009 at 10:05am

It almost doesn't matter who the other couples in the Bottom 3 are, Jonathan and Karla are inevitably doomed.

I had major doubts about Kupono partnering Kayla this week (especially in a Viennese waltz), but they really surprised me. Easily one of my favorite routines of the night. They made it look just effortless. Other favorites of the week: Evan & Randi (only Mia Michaels could dream up something so ridiculously hilarious) and Jeanette & Brandon (fun routine with lots of attitude and I was glad to see the props department held on to that throne).

I wasn't a huge fan of the Paso Doble either, Cathy. The music & costumes were genius, but the dancing was just so-so for me. Those lifts at the beginning were great, but it quickly fizzled out after that. Other dances I disliked: Asuka & Vitolio and Phillip & Jeanine. Both routines had a lot of potential to be great, but they ended up flopping.

Bob: you should definitely offer to be Kayla's stylist. Love the girl to death, but Jiminy Cricket -- that hair! Fix it! Please?

Randi: can I have a 'Unitard Girl' t-shirt too?! Seriously, you should market those suckers!

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.

Recent Comments

Joe said:

Who knows what brand and model of Ted Dansons glasses???????

about "CSI" Season 12: Welcome, Ted Danson

andy the geordie said:

Heejun was hysterical. Limited vocally, but a pure comedian. His little 'to the camera' synical...

about "American Idol" 2012: Hollywood Week, Part 2: Group Round

lyndon said:

I thought this was a singing contest, not a new "DRAMA" on FOX. There were no contestants thant...

about "American Idol" 2012: Hollywood Week, Part 1

Alan said:

We had last week's "teaser ending" nose dive from the stage (apparently more ambulances to...

about "American Idol" 2012: Hollywood Week, Part 1

Eric said:

So I missed the only interesting thing to happen all night? Amazing. Thank you for adding that,...

about "American Idol" 2012: Hollywood Week, Part 1