Rowe Photo
City Blogs: Music Blog

October 9, 2009 at 10:51am

CONCERT REVIEW: RPO opening night at Kodak Hall

Recommend Blog Post
Total Recommendations (0)

Last night the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra, with the help of the Rochester Oratorio Society, officially re-opened the Eastman Theatre, and rechristened it Kodak Hall. The program lived up to the momentous occasion, with the debut of a spectacular new work written explicitly for the night, and the performance of a bombastic standby that punctuated the evening.

In just 91 days our grandest local performance venue was made even more grand, with new lobby space and seating areas, improvements to the heating and cooling system, replacement of all of the seats in the orchestra level (the new ones are firm, but comfortable), and most noticeably, the addition of box seats to the orchestra and mezzanine levels. The design and construction teams did an amazing job matching the boxes to the original architecture, and in my opinion they really do add to the aesthetics of the venue, rather than detract. In other words, I want one.

After opening remarks by RPO president Charlie Owens and UR's Joel Seligman, the music started with the national anthem, led off by a drum roll performed on a snare that was played during the original opening of the Eastman Theatre in 1922. That was a classy touch. After that the RPO launched into the world premiere of a new work commissioned specifically for the event, "Geo," composed by Eastman School of Music Dean Douglas Lowry. The piece was meant to pay homage to, and represent the life of, the man ultimately responsible for everything the audience saw that night: George Eastman.

Prior to the concert I wondered how someone could capture George Eastman's story musically. Lowry obviously had the answer; "Geo" is a fantastic piece that really does encapsulate Eastman and his world perfectly. It sounds unmistakably American, of the 20th century, and most important, cinematic - appropriate for the guy who gave the world film. The piece also clearly reflected the storyline Lowry included in the program, with a clarion call awakening Eastman's spirit, inviting him to take a look at the improvements to his beloved theater, followed by a waltz with the spirit of his mother, and then a sonic exploration of music evoking the majesty of film. The work featured moments of triumph and sadness, both fitting for Eastman's life, and I felt as though the dynamic ending was almost a call to action to the audience, as if to say, "Look around you at what one man did for this city. It's amazing, but lots of work remains to be done."

Following intermission, the RPO concluded the program with Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, also featuring the Oratorio Society and soloists Barbara Shirvis, Jami Tyzik, Charles Reid, and Kevin Deas. There's really not much more anyone can write about the Ninth Symphony, and of course the RPO played it brilliantly. But I will say that, compared to the vigor with which the orchestra attacked "Geo," it almost felt as though the Beethoven piece lacked some energy. At least, until the final movement, when the orchestra, the chorus, and the soloists all belted it out.

The big question about the new Eastman - excuse me, Kodak Hall (that's going to take some getting used to) - was the acoustics. Depending on who you talked to, opinions on the acoustics in the original Eastman were somewhere between good and complicated. Now, following the renovations, the shape of the theater has changed, which has had an impact on how sound travels through it.

My seat last night was on the right-most row in the front-center orchestra section, and things sounded crystal clear. The horns in particular enveloped me, and it sounded as though the bass was sitting right next to my ear. However, I did find myself straining at times to hear the upper-register strings during "Geo," so I did a little experiment, and switched seats with a friend during intermission. Sitting in the left orchestra section during the Beethoven, I found the reverse situation to be true: the strings dominated, while the horns took on a secondary role.

Part of this is unavoidable: you're obviously going to hear more of what you're sitting in front of. And from both of my seats I had no problem appreciating the orchestra as a whole - it's not like you couldn't hear certain sections at all. The only time that was true was when the Oratorio Society joined in toward the end of the Ninth Symphony. When the entire orchestra was on blast, I could not hear a note the ROS was singing; it was as if dozens of mouths were opening wide but nothing was coming out.

Comments for "CONCERT REVIEW: RPO opening night at Kodak Hall" (2)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.

User Photo

Louis Richards said on Oct. 09, 2009 at 3:05pm

I attended the RPO rehearsal Thursday morning and was shocked by the improved accoustics. Though I have haunted the theatre for over half-a-century, I have never heard such crystal clarity and I plan to attend the concert by New York's finest orchestra (outside of NYC) when the Eastman Philharmonia plays Friday evening.

I don't completely understand the addition of Box Seats. Surely George Eastman could have placed them in his original plan; several of his other theatres had them at the time the theatre was built. But, I suppose it affords Rochester's Beau Monde (shabby as they may be) an opportunity to ogle one another across the theatre.

The name-change is ridiculous, of course. Eastman, himself, could have named the theatre Kodak Hall; he did not. Perhaps Kodak CEO, Antonio Perez, has the desire to leave a "legacy" in Rochester other than presiding over a company whose stock declined from Blue Chip to Buffalo Chip.

Some, like myself, may eschew the alterations; others may embrace them. Regardless, the accoustics are superb!

User Photo

Phil Lederer said on Oct. 10, 2009 at 10:59pm

I attended the Friday night concert of the Eastman Philharmonia. I sat in two different locations-orchestra center and the first row of the upper balcony.
From both the sound was much improved. On the main floor, where the sound used to just fly over you with poor mix and lack of presence, there was much more "immediacy" and directionality. The sound was much warmer than before. Indeed the sound was really bass focused, not the midrange diffuse sound before. As before the woodwinds showed well, but now the violas, celli and bass(i?) carried some weight. I heard the opening Beethoven, which is not top drawer and the noisy overplayed Shostakovich 5 on the main floor.
For the second piece I sat in the first row of the upper balcony. The Tchaikovsky Rococco Variations the solist (the excellent Michael Kaufman) could be heard with very warm, clear, focused sound.

The orchestra sound was pleasantly blended, and if I dare say, with somewhat of a "glow". I actually preferred the sound upstairs.

I never sit in the mezzanine so I cannot comment on the acoustics from there.

My perspective is a listener who has attended very few RPO concerts in recent years--I find Seaman to be a lightweight. So my opinion is largely based upon before the stage renovations of a few years ago. In all, the apparent transformation from a mediocre hall to a very good one is quite surprising. In my lifetime most acoustic fiddling by the experts has been very disappointing. This case is really an exception.

Is the hall "world class"? Not really. The old halls like the Concertgebouw have wooden floors--there the hall shakes and the sound is all involving and enveloping. But for modern hall, I have not heard better.

Other's opinions?

Phil Lederer
Rochester NY

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.

Recent Comments

Kristen Maxfield said:

Hey thanks so much Emily!!!! We appreciate your support and look forward to seeing you groove at...

about MUSIC REVIEW: Kristen Maxfield, Troyka at Water Street

Emily said:

What an amazing musical relationship between Toryka and Maxfield. They grooved, they moved,...

about MUSIC REVIEW: Kristen Maxfield, Troyka at Water Street

Frank Rhodes said:

Frank, You hit the nail on the head!! Is Keith Wyatt the same Keith Wyatt that endorsed Fender...

about CONCERT REVIEW: The Blasters at Castaways

Bill Baldwin said:

It certainly was a great night for a Blasters fan. My hometown of Syracuse was very well...

about CONCERT REVIEW: The Blasters at Castaways

tom petty tickets said:

Tom Petty is always great to see in concert i have seen him many times. I know i will be going...

about CONCERT UPDATE: Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers at Darien Lake