Ceridwen Troy is tall and slender with shoulder-length chestnut hair that she nervously swipesbehind her ear with her fingers. The 24-year-old is like a restless filly, ready to bolt, as she talks about her childhood. Raised in Wallace, a speck of a community in Steuben County, Troy says she began having questions about her gender when she was a teenager.
"I remember being 14 or 15 years old and already having given up on the thought of ever having a family," she says. "I wasn't what the people around me were seeing."
Troy didn't know how to express what she was experiencing at the time. We all live in a gendered society, she says. But the Jehovah's Witness society she was raised in is extremely conservative and hyper-gendered, she says.
"In my religion, the idea was that if you were a man, you would have a wife and children, and you would provide for them as the patriarchal head of the household," she says. "But when ‘man' doesn't work for you, the rest of it falls apart. And there was suddenly no future for me. I would cry myself to sleep at night, not knowing why praying wasn't enough to help me."
Troy tried throwing herself into her religion, and at 15 she became a minister. But she gradually broke away from the faith - she says she didn't fit in - and was accepted at SUNY Geneseo. It was in the beginning of her freshman year that she heard the word "transgender" for the first time.
"There was just this bizarre moment, when I thought ‘Oh my God, you mean there's a word for this?'" Troy says.
Transgender is frequently used as an umbrella term in the LGBT community. But the transgender world is so diverse, it is more like a mobile of suspended adjectives and pronouns that are interrelated; yet they move freely from one to another. Mention "transgender" and many people will think of entertainer RuPaul or actor Tim Curry as Dr. Frank-n-Furter in the ‘70's cult classic "the Rocky Horror Picture Show." But these drag characters are rich stereotypes that don't represent most people in the transgender community.
People who are transgender don't identify with their biological gender and don't conform to society's traditional expectations of gender. Some transgender people will fully change their male or female anatomy through various medical procedures - sometimes referred to as "gender reassignment." Some pursue partial changes. And still others don't undergo any medically induced changes at all. But they might express their gender by the way they dress or through their behavior.
No one knows the exact size of the transgender community locally or nationwide. It is generally thought to be a segment of the larger LGBT community, which by most accounts is less than 10 percent of the population. Differences in gender expression and identity are nothing new; they've been found inancient civilizations. Native Americans, for instance, recognized that some people possessed what they called "two spirits," the essences of both sexes in one body.
But the transgender community in the 21st century is testing, at least in Western cultures, the understanding of gender and sexuality. Some social, legal, and medical questions are being explored for the first time. For instance, does a T-woman - a man who becomes a woman - need both breast and prostate cancer screenings? Possibly, since most reassignment surgeries performed on males do not include removing the prostate gland.
And a T-man - a woman who becomes a man - should logically be sexually attracted to women, right? Not necessarily; sexual orientation doesn't always correlate to gender.
The transgender community, given this extreme diversity, is often isolated, the target of discrimination, and misunderstood. Despite those challenges, most transgender people will tell you it beats living a life that feels like a mistake, a deformity, and a lie.
Troy found confidence and a sense of personal freedom at college. By the end of her sophomore year, shebegan, in the parlance of the transgender community, to "transition." It's a gradual process that takes months, sometimes years. Some people describe it as a corrective realignment of the mind and the body.
"I started dressing more like the way I wanted to," she says. "And I grew my hair out."
Troy began taking hormones, which make masculine characteristics like body and facial hair less pronounced. But discussing the medical aspects of her transition makes Troy bristle.
"It's my medical history that we're talking about here," she says. "I mean, I get that people are curious, but to me it's a rather mundane thing."
She's not offended by questions about whether she's taking hormones. But she rolls her eyes at the one question she says everyone asks, "Have you had the surgery?" Troy says she would urge people to take a step back and ask themselves why they want to know. Understanding the complex relationship that the transgender community has with the medical community is more relevant, she says.
"There are so many hoops you have to jump through," she says. "There is a relationship with the medical community at large that is very conflicted."
Caring for transgender patients, especially when it comes to surgery, is a sub-specialty. Finding experienced doctors takes research and tenacity. Most doctors lack sufficient training in treating transgender people, and some have ethical problems working with them.
The lack of access to affordable and appropriate health care is the biggest issue most people in the transgender community face, says Christopher Hinesley, a T-man and former director of the Gay Alliance of the Genesee Valley.
"Most medical procedures aren't covered by health insurance," he says. "But some procedures are required in order to legally recognize the change."
This creates a conundrum for many people, because it touches on the second most important issue transgender people face: employment.
"How do you maintain a job when you're going through such a dramatic change in your life?" Hinesley says. "Yet you need employment in order to pay for the medical procedures."
Proper health care is also important for those people who self-identify with a gender, Hinesley says, and they want to "pass" undetected as that gender. Some people don't care if they pass or not, but for those who do, it can be a painful experience knowing that they don't, he says. It can add to employment difficulties, and for some transgender people, it can be dangerous to be out in public.
"It's been a long time since the gay and lesbian community had to be closeted as a whole community," Hinesley says. "But that's really where the trans community is today; we're like 30 years behind the progress made by the larger LGB community. You can lose your job, your family, and your friends. You can lose it all."
And there is resentment about it.
The transgender community is still fighting for basic protections, while the LGB community is busy fighting for marriage equality, says Pamela Barres, a T-woman and co-director of the Rochester chapter of the New York Transgender Rights Organization.
"It seems like we're being run over by the marriage express people," she says. "This is what everyone is talking about. It's what the media talks about. But when it comes right down to it, marriage equality is a happiness bill. I don't want to prioritize, but we need protection from discrimination for transgender people."
The transgender community was slighted by the 2002 passage of the state Sexual Orientation Non-Discrimination Act, which protects people from housing and employment discrimination based on sexual orientation. The legislation did not include the transgender community. The Gender Expression Non-Discrimination Act is intended to correct that omission. GENDA passed the New York State Assembly last year, but it has not been approved in the Senate.
"As a political movement, more and more of us are standing up and saying ‘We're here, too,'" says Barres.
But the risk of rejection and ridicule, as Troy has learned, is real and at times, heartbreaking.
A confrontation with her mother had been brewing for years. During one spring break, Troy was at home eating breakfast when her mother came downstairs. She could tell by the way her mother looked at her that she was pissed, Troy says.
"Why don't you want to be a man?" her mother asked.
Troy knew the answer would only anger her mother more.
Highly educated people in the transgender community may have a slight shield against employment discrimination compared to those who don't. When one of Bill Pickett's twin sons told him that he was transgender, Pickett wasn't too concerned about his son's livelihood. Lawrence University, his son's employer, was extremely supportive of the astrophysicist, Pickett says.
That was of some consolation to Pickett, but the former president of St. John Fisher College and father of seven children says that he was still rocked by his son's news.
"I had no clue," he says. "I had all of the other concerns you have when they're growing up - drugs, alcohol, illness, and accidents. I never once thought about this. The only exposure to it I had was watching one of those shows like ‘Jerry Springer.'"
Pickett was concerned that his grown son, Brian, a married man and the father of two young children, might be delusional and having some type of mental breakdown. What he discovered, he says, was something worse.
"He told me about his journey, through a letter," Pickett says. "He told me that he had attempted suicide. That's because shame becomes such an inherent part of their personality. And that discovery was chilling for me because I realized right there that I could have lost my child."
In a matter of a few weeks, Pickett had to become accustomed to his new daughter, Megan. Pickett insisted on being by her bedside through the surgical transition. But it was only the beginning of a long and difficult process for the entire family.
Seven years later, Pickett says he has grown to love and respect his daughter. But he couldn't be dishonest about his feelings, either.
"It was a sense of profound loss," he says. "It was like a death. I told Megan this. I told her that I miss Brian and if it were up to me, I wouldn't have changed a thing."
Pickett was not the only person unprepared for Brian's transition to Megan; her twin brother, Sean, was shocked and angered.
"Like a lot of twins, they were very close," Pickett says. "It was a lot like a relationship with a spouse. He asked some of the same questions. He wanted to know, ‘Who were you all of this time?'"
The bigger question for the whole family, Pickett says, was the effect this would have on Megan's children.
"When you do something like this, you're going to hurt people," Pickett says. "It's one thing when you're talking about adults, but it's another when you're talking about your children; how can you do this to an 11-year-old son and a 9-year-old daughter? There's going to be collateral damage."
Megan's relationship with most of her siblings remains tense. They've all had to make adjustments, Pickett says.
"I knew that I cared about this relationship, so I had to be proactive about it," Pickett says. "But the relationship between Megan and Sean has not been reestablished. And I said to Megan, ‘You have to work at this. You're the one who changed; he didn't.'"
Married to her when she was Brian, Megan's wife wasn't O.K. with the change, either, and left.
"I love all of my children," Pickett says. "But I learned that I can't determine where their relationships with each other will end up."
Pickett says he is sometimes approached by other parents trying to cope with situations similar to the one his family is experiencing.
"I tell them that this is a real medical condition that needs to be resolved," he says. "And I tell them that they need to be the same mother and father they always were to their son or daughter. Remember that nobody has died. Nobody is going to prison. Don't draw lines when it comes to these relationships and you'll get through it. That's what I learned: We can all get through this if we try."





Comments for "TransRochester" (9)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.
The GVGL said on Jul. 17, 2009 at 12:16am
As a sexual minority myself it was interesting to read the ‘TransRochester‘ story about a transgendered woman, Ceridwen Troy. I can identify with many of the issues faced by Ceridwen. I too once knew that I was different, but didn’t even have words to describe the difference. I too would face rejection and ridicule if my orientation were known. Like Ceridwen, I have no protection against discriminate in employment and housing.
But I couldn’t help but notice the difference in tone between ‘TransRochester‘, which was supportive and sympathetic, and the earlier story about me, ‘CYBERSPACE: Cyber creeps‘, which described the contents of my blog as ‘revolting’. What is the difference? Ceridwen was born male, but feels she was really meant to be female, takes hormones to subdue masculine characteristics, and dresses and grooms as a female. Me? My affectionate orientation (the persons for whom I feel aesthetic, romantic, and sexual attraction) are primarily prepubescent females.
Ceridwen and I probably have a lot more in common that most people would think, but the differences in our treatment, by the City Newspaper, by the GLB comunity, and by society at large couldn’t be more stark. And I for one don’t see and valid reason why this should be tolerated by a decent and civil society.
Eric said on Jul. 17, 2009 at 11:41am
To GVGL: Regarding the point that City Newspaper treated Ceridwen Troy and the transgendered community of Rochester differently than we previously treated Genesee Valley Girl Lover and the local pedosexual community, that is true. We did treat them differently, because they ARE different. The gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender community is fighting for equal treatment -- by society and by the law -- so that relationships between consenting adults can be protected. Pedosexuals, by definition, are seeking protection for their relationships with or romantic/sexual interest in pre-pubescent children. To even compare a consensual adult relationship to what is essentially the sexual abuse of a child is offensive to the GLBT community, and it is something that City Newspaper certainly does not support.
We debated in the City newsroom whether or not to approve this comment, as it stirred up many conflicting emotions among the staff. But we decided that the comment did not run afoul of any of our policies (it is not libelous, it does not use hate speech, it does not attack any other posters), and it could spark a meaningful debate among our users. But please note: this website will not allow hate speech or personal attacks on any other posters; those comments will be edited or deleted. Otherwise, please feel free to post your own thoughts on either the above story or the issue raised by GVGL in his comment.
--Eric Rezsnyak, Features Editor, City Newspaper
Bernie said on Jul. 17, 2009 at 4:24pm
After reading both articles. I feel that they are 2 completely different subjects. GVGL, you may want to be put under the same umbrella as GLBT community, but I don't see them as the same. And I don't mean to anger you by my opinion, but your issue to me has to do with the mental capacity or age of your intended interest.
Ceridwen said on Jul. 19, 2009 at 10:20am
"Ceridwen and I probably have a lot more in common that most people would think..."
No, we really don't.
That's the only thing I can bring myself to say.
The GVGL said on Jul. 20, 2009 at 12:02am
Eric, thank you for the reply. Before going any further I should acknowledge that City Newspaper's article, 'CYBERSPACE: Cyber creeps', about me and my Genesee Valley Girl Lover blog was in fact more fair than most such articles about people like myself. But I hope the irony is not lost that an article with 'creep' in the title and 'revolting' in the second paragraph is actually more fair and balanced than most such articles.
You said in your reply to me that “The gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender community is fighting for equal treatment -- by society and by the law -- so that relationships between consenting adults can be protected.” I understand what you are saying, but reading 'TransRochester' it is very clear that Ceridwen's issues do not primarily concern her ability to have consensual relationships with other adults. If that were the case, then her situation would be adequately covered by the GLB aspect of GLBT, with no need for the 'T'. The 'T' is needed though because transgendered people face discrimination by society and law, in many areas of their lives, because of who or what they are, not because they do anything illegal. Similarly, I as a pedosexual face discrimination because of who or what I am, not because of anything I do or have done.
Further on you say “Pedosexuals, by definition, are seeking protection for their relationships with or romantic/sexual interest in pre-pubescent children. To even compare a consensual adult relationship to what is essentially the sexual abuse of a child is offensive to the GLBT community, and it is something that City Newspaper certainly does not support.” I have never suggested that relationships between two adults are equivalent to relationships between pedosexuals and children. I'd be the first to acknowledge that legal relationships between pedosexuals and children (and no, that's not an oxymoron, I'm in such a relationship) are by their nature VERY different from relationships between two adults. Of course, when we support a GLBT person's right to be free of job discrimination, housing discrimination, and physical assault, we are not supporting or condoning them committing rape or sexual assault. By the same token, supporting my right to be free from discrimination and violence need not suggest support for sexual relationships between myself and prepubescent girls.
In closing, I should give kudos to City Newspaper for even publishing my original comment. Many other sites engage in outright censorship of online pedosexuals, prohibiting any participation by them at all, simply because they admit to being pedosexuals. On the other hand, your comment about the debate in the City Newsroom over whether or not to approve my comment, thought it did not violate any of your policies, suggests to me that I am treated very differently than other people simple because of who I am, not what I do.
J said on Jul. 20, 2009 at 9:52am
Please do not disregard my question as a joke or an attempt to fan the flames, it is an honest question... What is the difference between a "pedosexual" and a pedophile?
Danielleg said on Jul. 21, 2009 at 11:32pm
I am proud of Ceridwen in that she is able to look in the mirror now and be happy. I admire you and look up to you. I am older than you but feel you are much older in spirit. I am 29, and female.
I have a crush on you
love,
Danielle G.
Truth said on Sep. 10, 2009 at 2:39pm
J; to answer your question: the words pedophile and pedosexual are nearly Synonymous in definition but carry very different connotations. The word pedophile (which sounds like defile) is inherently negative and feeds the stereotype that all pedo’s are corrupt, evil, child molesters out to take advantage of children for their own needs. The word pedosexual simply notes sexuality just as Heterosexual and homosexual do. Further more, I would like to take this opportunity to share with all of you: We (the pedo's) seek to live in harmony with you. We grow tired of hiding in the shadows, we want to be accepted for who we are. It’s time that we were looked upon with the compassion and understanding that you have shown others. All oppressed groups have fought and earned their rights. Women, Minorities, Homosexuals, transgender. Is it not time that we (the pedo's) earned the right to walk in the light?
Sas said on Nov. 21, 2009 at 1:27am
Eric, is it really appropriate to allow this article to be co-opted by a pedo discussion when there's already been an article about that? It's deeply offensive to have the spotlight on trans people stolen by GVGL's cause.
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.