Marketview Liquor
City Blogs: News Blog

August 7, 2009 at 11:31am

MOULE: Health-care hijinks

Recommend Blog Post
Total Recommendations (0)

The most telling moment in Representative Eric Massa's health-care town hall meeting last night was when he asked for a show of hands on whether he should support the bill. Almost every hand went up as a "no."

The problem, though, was that there was no delineation between those who didn't like the bill because it expands the government's role, or because it didn't give the government enough of a role. It was just a simple yes or no vote.

But so goes the health-care debate, which last night was more of a shouting match. Take this little gem: One guy asked how private insurance companies can compete with a government plan, and someone else yells "Be better."

Across the country, conservative groups have been mobilizing speakers to go to these meetings with the sole purpose of disrupting them or embarrassing members of Congress. At Massa's meeting last night, pro-health care reform groups, like Health Care for America Now, came out to show support for reform. In the end, it was hard to tell if any "average citizens" came out and spoke, or if it was a lot of people acting on behalf of one campaign or another.

The hecklers may have underestimated their target, however. As Massa made his opening remarks, some guy yelled out, "Can we ask a question soon?" to which Massa simply replied, "In a few minutes," and kept going. And when other people yelled things like "Tell Nancy Pelosi," he simply kept talking in his booming voice.

Really, Massa came out of this looking better than anyone in the crowd. When the two sides started yelling at each other, he urged them to calm down and to let the person with the floor speak, and he reassured them he'd take as many questions as he possibly could. He answered uncomfortable questions honestly - he refused to commit to not raising taxes to pay for health care, for example.

For a good nuts-and-bolts summary of the meeting, check out this Politico story.

Massa tried to drive home a couple of other points: He trying to slow down a current health-care bill, H.R. 3200, because he has concerns about it: a cost share for states was one problem he has with it, but he's also unhappy that it lacks a strong public option.

A single-payer health care system would still be best, Massa said.

Comments for "MOULE: Health-care hijinks" (2)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.

User Photo

Phillip Dampier said on Aug. 07, 2009 at 6:05pm

Thank you! It's a point I failed to bring up on my own blog post about the entire event (phillipdampier.com). I kept my hand down on that vote because with so many bills (and Democrat blue dogs throwing our priorities under the bus), I am not exactly sure what bill we're talking about.

It would have been far better to ask, who wants single payer, who wants public option, who wants co-ops, and who wants absolutely nothing but more of the same.

In the end, it was one big rendition of the Special Interest Players' Theatre of the Absurd.

From the Glenn Beck "rodeo clowns" screaming and interrupting to the anti-government Ayn Rand fan club members, to the progressives afraid it's all going to be a watered down mess in the end, the overwhelming majority of the event was much more about the audience playing to the media (or cell phone/video cameras for later blog postings), instead of the star of the show - Rep. Eric Massa.

The good news for him is that he was the only one who masterfully maneuvered around everyone's talking points, pre-conceived notions, and rhetoric. Whether you agreed or disagreed, at least you heard a congressman speak what he really believed instead of the usual political doublespeak you get from a lot of these events.

In the end, I don't believe anyone's position changed at all about anything.

User Photo

stlo7 said on Aug. 09, 2009 at 7:45pm

We have started posting video of the Town hall meeting. at our site -

http://rochesterturning.com/2009/08/09/rep-massa-town-hall-video-opening-remarks-and-dispeling-myths/

http://rochesterturning.com/2009/08/09/first-question-everyone-already-has-health-care-why-reform-it/

I'll post more as time permits.

I also agree with both Jeremy Moule and commenter Phillip. Massa was on his game.

Pop over and visit -

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.

Recent Comments

tdub said:

Arrest Obama for treason? For what? Winning an election? OK.... I think the main point that...

about Iowa Rep. ponders revolution

Mpeach Obama said:

So, basic American principles include giving non-citizens the same rights as Americans?

about Have Dick and Liz Cheney wigged out?

Ronald Schofell said:

This villages dissolusion has one thing that ours will not however hard they try and that is...

about Seneca Falls will dissolve village; others are watching

noyb said:

When can we arrest Obama for treason?

about Iowa Rep. ponders revolution

KNARF said:

That's amazing. I wonder if he can be arrested for treason. When President Bush told a bold...

about Iowa Rep. ponders revolution