City Blogs: News Blog

November 4, 2009 at 4:32pm

ELECTION 2009: WTF happened?

Recommend Blog Post
Total Recommendations (2)

Somewhere, Steve Minarik is smiling.

Despite Robutrad, despite the scandals in the Greece Police Department, despite the older scandals of the selection of the public defender and the MCC president, Monroe County Republicans waltzed away with all of the prizes yesterday.

All of them.

Democrats won the city races, of course, but the Republicans barely put in an appearance there. Out in the suburbs, where the Dems needed to pick up only one seat to take control of the County Legislature, and where they had some strong candidates in several races, Republicans made a clean sweep. They hung onto all of their seats in the Lej, and thus their one-vote margin of control. They grabbed control of two suburban towns from the Democrats -Irondequoit (where there are more registered Dems than Republicans) and Mendon.

And in race after race, the Dems didn't even come close.

What happened? And what, if anything, does this mean?

Some preliminary thoughts:

  • If the few voters who turned out yesterday are representative, the divide between the city and its suburbs has sharpened.
  • Monroe Democrats have been gaining voter-registration strength, but the often-overlooked "blanks" - voters who aren't registered with any party - liked the Republicans in this election.
  • If the Dems couldn't pick up a single seat in the County Legislature in this environment, how relevant will the party be in the suburbs in the future? What do they need? A new message? A new leader? Rebuilding from the ground up?
  • Are jobs and taxes really the only issues that matter to Monroe County residents?
  • How much of this Republican sweep is due to voter disgust with the Democratic-run state government?
  • How much of it is due to suburban voter disenchantment (or worse) with Barack Obama? Is it oversimplifying to note that Republicans throughout New York State's suburbs had a good day yesterday - as they did in Virginia and New Jersey, where voters embraced Obama in last year's presidential election?
  • Voter turnout yesterday was abysmally low - around 32 percent - which may or may not have had anything to do with the results. Is that because everybody (except the folks in Irondequoit and Mendon) is satisfied? Because nobody cared about any of the races? Because voters are fed up with politics and think it doesn't matter who's in charge? (Local leaders sometimes seem to go out of their way to prove the point. City officials talk about having to cut expenses to the bone and then consider hiring the mayor's former campaign manager as fire marshal.)
  • In the past, County Legislature Republicans have paid little attention to their Democratic colleagues. They'll have no incentive to do so now, and that does not bode well for city residents.

Comments for "ELECTION 2009: WTF happened? " (7)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.

User Photo

Jason Olshefsky said on Nov. 05, 2009 at 7:16am

As a voter registered "independent" and not affiliated with any political party I don't think the collective term "blanks" properly captures my motivations. I suggest "non-sheeple".

I suspect that the party-line voting trend was simply based on non-Presidential election voters voting along party lines.

User Photo

Wanda Howard said on Nov. 05, 2009 at 12:55pm

As a longtime registered Democrat, I am not surprised by the Republican windfall. Democratic leaders have set a tone of distrust and division. Term limits should be in place for the Mayor, City Councit, NYS Assembly, and School Board. How effective can you be establishing growth in a city when you can't see past your own political ambitions. Advocacy for urban development is limited among our Democratic politicans. Republicans take care of thier own in the suburbs regardless of socio-economic status. Democrats will chalk this up to a loss and hope that residents will forget that they now are a party of politicians that just talk the talk. Republicans proved Tuesday they can walk they walk and bring young, new political leaders with them that they have no problem passing the torch to.

User Photo

Jebediah Brow said on Nov. 05, 2009 at 9:23pm

Suburbs aren't intellectually stimulating. The people who live there are Republican types, average Joes, modest in every way. The many registered Democrats are unenthusiastic moderates who were led into it.

User Photo

Voice of Reason said on Nov. 06, 2009 at 6:03pm

Maybe voters looked at Joe Morelle's votes in the Assembly, and the Assembly backgrounds of the Democrats in the county legislature (at least 5 of them basically work for Sheldon Silver, directly or indirectly) and concluded they didn't want the Monroe County legislature to raise the budget and taxes quite as fast as the Assembly does. Or maybe they don't want their towns run with the same quality schools and low crime rate as the City of Rochester, which the Democrats have done such a fine job with over the past 20 years.

User Photo

hiwayman17 said on Nov. 06, 2009 at 7:53pm

The county Republicans gave us ample reasons NOT to vote for them. However, the Democrats, under the poor leadership of Joe Morelle, gave us NO reason to vote for them. The Dem's lit was all about how terrible and corrupt the Republicans seem to be. But I know from the mail I got, the Dem candidate in my area not once mentioned any of his ideas or plans. Maybe he didn't have any. I'll never know since he lost.

Joe Morelle either needs to resign immediately or allow the fresh candidates who want to run for office to actually speak for themselves. Once candidates are under the wing of MCDC, original ideas are replaced by generic blandness. Candidates should be about ideas and plans. If they aren't they shouldn't be running.

User Photo

clint said on Nov. 07, 2009 at 4:24pm

I saw a television ad that said it all...Joe Morelle is bringing Albany style politics to Rochester! The truth is that rather than leading, the Democrats have become the party of "no"! They do not float real ideas, they simply always say no! It is sadly true that a number of them work in the NYS Assembly and now want to bring that approach to governement here...No Thanks!

Look at what happened this election. A vicious attack ad on a Judge paid for by the Democrat Party...then no aplologie from the Chairman for running it...then Fair Campaign Practices violations (two in a week)...then he even loses his own town back to the Republicans. He loses the legislature which appeared to be his...and, he still has no apologies.

He set up his own town supervisor for defeat by dragging his feet on Medley Center funding...he rejects the idea of a theatre in his own district to force it downtown...and, he takes his orders from Sheldon Silver...not us, the people that elect him! It is time for Joe to Go! Both as Chair...and from the Assembly...we need someone who cares for our future...not his own power

User Photo

Harry Davis said on Nov. 08, 2009 at 9:44pm

In April, just before I decided to run for Rochester City Council, I was told by a Democratic leader that this would be a futile task for me, as all of the decisions had already been made. I was then, and am now, attempting to get a job with the Obama administration in the Health and Human Services Department in Washington to help get stem cell & regenerative medicine resources out to where they are needed. This leader told me to stay focused on the DC possibility and forget playing local politics, because I had no chance with it.

Obviously, I did not follow this man's advice! I am happy that when I began this course in April that I was one of 20 candidates for City Council. In the end, I was one of 6 candidates for city council thanks to my nomination and endorsement by the Working Families Party. And I thank very much the 1,694 of you who voted for me!
I still want to bring CHANGE to Rochester. I want a downtown that is civilized, where one can live; not the wasteland it is today. The way this will happen is when we have a true democracy in Rochester. Less than 10% of the voters actually chose our leaders this election, in the sense that very few people were involved in the Democratic Party endorsement and nomination process. This process was a travesty as we know from Tom Brennan's experience running for Commissioner of Schools, where in three of the City's LD committees, he came in third place. But like all the other candidates who did not get 50% of the committee vote; Tom had to enter a run-off at Party convention with the convoluted rule that committee votes for the run-off candidates were entirely up to the LD leader, all of which gave all their votes to David Gantt's darling Cynthia Elliott, in spite of the fact that she received no more than a few votes from the original committee caucuses while Tom received the third highest in each. Word on the street has it that this was the result of a deal struck with Gantt to endorse her (almost assuring the nomination as well); and in return he would not run another City Council candidate to oppose the others.


Joe Morelle, who presided over this process fixing, either needs to resign immediately or allow the fresh candidates who want to run for office to actually speak for themselves. Once candidates are under the wing of MCDC, original ideas are replaced by generic blandness. Candidates should be about ideas and plans. If they aren't, they shouldn't be running.


An example of this was evident when I and the other City Council candidates presented ourselves in caucus to the committee that David Gantt controls. We all made speeches presenting our case in hopes of a real vote. Mr. Gantt did not even bother to stay in the room to listen to what I had to say, about Renaissance Square, about high tech possibilities with stem cell research for jobs in our area, and for high speed rail. Mr. Gantt was not even in the room when all of us spoke to his committee! Mr. Gannt was outside, seen through the glass window, smoking a cigarette during the entire process! And, when the votes were tallied for David's committee, it was unanimous. EVERYBODY David chose had EXACTLY the same amount of votes!! And who was the leader of the MCDC when this happened? Joe Morelle, that's who.

By closing out the process in the committees the way it did, it insured a low turn-out in the City, which hurt the County-wide races.

I will be holding an event in a couple of months to have a better look at where we are all going politically. I will invite Green Party members, Working Family members, and all of you who have no political affiliation. If the Democratic Party in Monroe County wants to succeed, I think it is time we all looked at where it's leadership has taken it and decide if we want to continue in the same direction.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.


Recent Comments

Jay Betts said:

Same old crap you hear from all the networks, try other sources of media for your knowledge. ...

about SARAH PALIN: Our modern-day Anita Bryant

Louis Richards said:

I have heard several comparisons that name the Raleigh-Durham area, which hosts a population...

about RBTL: Canal Ponds makes its pitch

Harry Davis said:

In April, just before I decided to run for Rochester City Council, I was told by a Democratic...

about ELECTION 2009: WTF happened?

rochester99 said:

It’s also a tactic to ”low ball” the construction cost…especially with public sector...

about RBTL: Canal Ponds makes its pitch

arnie rothschild said:

There has been one development, not reported about the PAC that was reinforced in the private...

about RBTL: Canal Ponds makes its pitch