March 16, 2010 at 10:43am
A friend asked over the weekend how I'm feeling about Obama. Well, nervous, but still strongly in support. I wish the fate of his presidency didn't seem to be riding on what Congress does with health-care reform this week, though.
I sympathize a bit with the Democrats who are still wavering; this is complicated stuff. But I'm still convinced that the House ought to pass the Senate bill, blemishes and all. It's a start. And if this attempt fails, I can't imagine that any president in the next couple of decades will have the courage to try again. So we'll be stuck with escalating costs and a growing number of uninsured.
I also think that A) if the bill passes, the furor will die down, and Americans will like what they see in the bill, and B) the Democrats (and surely, surely, a few reasonable Republicans) will act on other important things, burying the charge that they can't get anything done.
That said, I found two pieces in today's New York Times particularly challenging and informative: David Brooks' "The Spirit of Sympathy" and "The Health Care Letdown," by William Pewen, a former health-policy advisor for Maine's Senator Olympia Snowe.
Brooks bemoans the bitterness and partisanship that has developed in the Senate, where across-the-aisle, interpersonal relationships once were common. And he warns against passing bills by reconciliation, which Democrats may attempt with health care. "Once partisan reconciliation is used for this bill," Brooks writes, "it will be used for everything, now and forever." And in the Senate, he writes, "the remnants of person-to-person relationships, with their sympathy and sentiment, will be snuffed out."
Pewen shines some light on the attempts at bipartisanship in the health-care deliberations, and he finds fault with both Republicans and Democrats. For instance: "many Republicans had decided even before Inauguration Day to block reform," he writes, "including policies that their party had previously supported." And rather than tackle legitimate concerns like how much Americans would have to pay for insurance under a mandated plan, "the Democratic leadership, in the interest of political expediency, expanded the scope of the legislation, adding more regulation, spending, and taxes. Soon health care reform, which had been achievable, became endangered."
And, he writes, while Democrats first insisted on having a public option as part of reform, they later abandoned it, even though Snowe, a Republican, had herself offered public option as a fallback.
He chastises Democrats for killing a bipartisan proposal that would have permitted the importing of prescription drugs. Democrats had already nixed that important progressive step by cutting a deal with the pharmaceutical industry.
And he throws out a challenge to Republicans that I guess we can take some comfort in: If reform fails now, "Republicans should take no consolation," he writes. Whenever the country gets around to passing reform, "health costs and the number of uninsured and underinsured will have escalated - and the likely outcome will be the single-payer system that Republicans most abhor."
Both worth a read.

Hatred and prejudice is not the issue here. These same people already operate a mosque probably...
about The Ground Zero mosque that's not at Ground Zero and is not a mosque
Watch Greg Mortenson on Charlie Rose. He shows that our Generals understand far more than any of...
about Worth the read: on a Republican Congress and schools in Afghanistan
Thought this would be of interest to readers. Since September 2001 I have maintained a free...
about The Ground Zero mosque that's not at Ground Zero and is not a mosque
Thank you to Louise Slaughter, Dan Maffei and Dennis Kucinich. In January 2009, the wars in...
about House approves war funding; Slaughter, Maffei vote against
:: yawn :: If we really want to have an honest discussion about race (and ultimately fairness)...
Comments for "Worth a read: insights into the health-care debate" (0)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.
No comments have been posted. Be the first and add one below.
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.