September 22, 2011 at 11:30am
Uh....
Here in our news room, we've been scratching our heads about the "Vote, Be Heard" campaign ever since we heard about it yesterday.
The campaign's sponsors, the Rochester Business Alliance and the Rochester Faith Alliance, say the purpose is to get people to vote in the November election - specifically, to vote for school board members. The sponsors insist that they're not taking sides - that they simply want to increase voter registration and participation in this year's school board election. Those are good goals, but the campaign ran into trouble right out the door.
First, there are the posters and billboards that accompany the campaign. Some of them show black children with duct tape over their mouth. I'm not sure what that's supposed to signify, or what it has to do with people voting, but it has drawn sharp criticism from some black community leaders, which shouldn't be a surprise.
And it didn't take half a second for school board members - and candidates - to voice their suspicion about what the RBA and the Faith Alliance are really up to. Their hunch: that this is the beginning of another push for mayoral control of the school district.
Here's their reasoning:
Critics of mayoral control have argued that it's anti-democratic because it would take away people's right to vote for school board members. But voter participation for school board is notoriously low. In this month's Democratic primary for school board, for instance, only about 10 percent of registered voters showed up at the polls.
If the RBA and the Faith Alliance put on a big get-out-the-vote push and turnout is still low, maybe that will prove that the general public really doesn't want to be involved in electing school board members. And that would squash that anti-democracy argument against mayoral control.
Well, I don't know. It's a little far-fetched - but frankly, it's as good as any other rationale I can think of. If the RBA and the Faith Alliance were really pushing for more voter involvement in school board races, why didn't they do this campaign before the Democratic primary, which, in this heavily Democratic city, is usually the "real" election for city offices.
I wondered yesterday whether the RBA and the Faith Alliance were upset about the results of that Democratic primary and were hoping that big voter turnout in the November election would get different results. Do the RBA and the Faith Alliance secretly want Howard Eagle and Wallace Smith to get elected?
Apparently not.
Go to the RBA website and click on yesiamvoting.com and you'll find yet another problem with this trouble-ridden campaign.
The nicely designed website tells you when the voter registration deadline is, and how and where you can register, and when the November election is. And it helpfully gives you a list of the candidates for school board, with a bit of information about them - all of them except two.
Howard Eagle and Wallace Smith.
OK: I think I know how this happened. If you go to the Board of Elections website, you'll see a list of all of the school board candidates - except Eagle and Smith.
Eagle and Smith ran for school board in this month's primary and lost, but they're running in November as Green Party candidates. The Greens' candidates just aren't listed on the Board of Elections site yet.
But the omission from the RBA's website list just adds confusion to the RBA-Faith Alliance campaign.
And it seems to raise a question:
If RBA members and leaders are so interested in the Rochester school board election, wouldn't you think they'd know who is running?
Sadly very few people even know what ballast water is and could not care that NY wasted tax...
Where IS the outrage? How in god's name can Wilmorite say they need $11 million to 'develop' the...
about Doing the COMIDA shuffle
http://readme.readmedia.com/New-York-Pursues-Uniform-National-Ballast-Water-Requirements/3642280
In January 2009 According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Workforce Participation rate...
It's been almost 3 months since this article,,,,,,,, and it's gotten even worse. The whole...
about Has the GOP gone crazy?
Comments for "What the heck is with that Rochester Business Alliance campaign?" (11)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.
Howie Jacobson said on Sep. 22, 2011 at 4:02pm
Please check the website www.yesiamvoting.com tomorrow afternoon. The site will be updated to include the other 2 candidates. The yesiamvoting.com site candidate information was provided by the Board of Election. As you noticed, the Board of Election did not have either. NOT the yesiamvoting fault for not including.
flowercityman said on Sep. 22, 2011 at 8:24pm
While it is always easier to blame someone else, that part is understandable. What remains curious, however, is the timing of the ad campaign and even more curious is the creative thinking behind putting duck tape over youngsters mouths.
Puleeeaaazzzee said on Sep. 22, 2011 at 8:50pm
Did you really think the Rochester Business Alliance would know enough about the City School District to list all the candidates. Does the RBA have ANY authority on issues of eduction? No one really believes that they do, except perhaps on issues related to how Republican cronies can get their hands the City School District budget for distribution to their other various friends. RBA, go back to school before you make matters worse. And Howie Jacobson: sounds like somebody needs to take responsibility for a big mistake and racially insensitive advertising.
b sarbane said on Sep. 23, 2011 at 8:30am
I am not a member of the RBA, but two things have been glaringly clear for a long time about the City School District to even the most casual observers: (a) the School Board is totally dysfunctional and incapable of moving forward with an agenda -- any agenda -- having to do with educating children; and (b) in the absence of any leadership, Adam Urbanski continues to effectively run the place for the benefit of his union. I have nothing against Malik, but no one in this town takes him seriously as a leader, and the endless bickering amongst the other Board members makes them all look self-promoting with petty agendas. Maybe what the RBA is saying is that we need change we can believe in, which means a new crop of Board members.
Small Businessman said on Sep. 23, 2011 at 11:38am
Does anyone really take the Rochester Business Alliance seriously except for a few close associates of Sandy Parker? The business community likes to complain a lot about problems in government, problems in education, problems with taxes, problems in regulation. Perhaps the business community, via the RBA, needs to look at itself as a source of ongoing lack of effectiveness. The RBA could stand to reform itself and perhaps a real change in leadership there is long overdue.
Carrie Remis said on Sep. 25, 2011 at 12:31pm
It’s troubling that this paper would use its influence to discredit this get out the vote drive instead of showcasing it. Troubling too that you didn’t reach out to more than the usual subjects before proclaiming a lack of support among the black community. Or reflect on the great potential of an alliance of the churches and the business community.
Communities with broad-based coalitions that aim to build civic capacity like these are the communities that have been successful in sustaining education reform. Rochester has historically found this sort of coalition-building difficultâ€"in large part due to snarky editorials like this. The status quo thrives on Rochester’s petty divisions and in-fighting that this piece aims to reinforce.
Howard J. Eagle said on Sep. 26, 2011 at 12:35pm
Ms. Remis,
Since you obviously support the RBA / FCA "get out the vote drive," particularly as it relates to the school board race ___ is it fair and accurate to assume that you also support the desperate need to break the local Democrat Party elite leadership's choke-hold relative to perpetuation of the entrenched status-quo? In other words, will you, and will the RBA and the FCA support candidates other than those who are hand-picked, and have the self-serving, Democrat Party leadership's stamp of approval? If so, then don't you think that it's wise (as part of the campaign) to let people know which candidate(s) you support? If this is not the intent, then would you or someone mind explaining what, exactly, specifically the get out the vote effort is all about? What is it designed to do? Hopefully, it is not merely a great, big, expensive, political scare tactic. If so, that would be a shame, and in my humble view, it would also represent a serious squander of very valuable resources, which could be better utilized to help support suffering RCSD children and families in concrete ways.
Sincerely,
Howard J. Eagle
Candidate for Rochester Board of Education (http://www.communityeducationslate.com)
Carrie Remis said on Sep. 27, 2011 at 9:42pm
@ Howard: As a 501c3 we can't endorse candidates, but we can certainly endorse a voter registration push. And I totally agree with you about the need for breaking the democratic party's "choke hold " on public eduation, only I question whether candidates with such close ties to the status quo like yourself (aka teachers unions) can deliver real change.
Peking Humonculous said on Sep. 28, 2011 at 11:18am
HAHAHA! Great reply, Carrie Remis!!!
Howard J. Eagle said on Sep. 29, 2011 at 5:26am
It is true that our organization (the Community Education Task Force) did in fact collaborate closely, not only with RTA, but RAP, BENTE, and even ASAR ___ before Brizard began to threaten and intimidate the latter group___ in the process of soundly defeating mayoral control, which I suspect you and many of your allies supported uncritically, and probably still do. In the process of stopping Sandra Parker, the big-business community, David Gantt, Joe Morelle and others ___ who really represent the epitome of the status quo ___ we developed an ongoing, valued, principled, working relationship with RTA and RAP in particular.
Howard J. Eagle said on Sep. 29, 2011 at 5:30am
As it relates to being the type of "candidate [that] can deliver real change," everyone understands that in order to deliver any type of change, a plan must exist. You can read about our work and our plan at communityeducationtaskforce.rocus.org, which was in fact developed in conjunction with RTA, RAP, BENTE, ASAR and a very broad cross section of parents, grandparents, students, educators and others within the Rochester community.
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.