Back to Opinion

URBAN JOURNAL: Are we powerless to fix Albany?

Recommend Article
Total Recommendations (0)

I don't know: what do you think will work? E-mail state senators and tell them we're fed up? Phone them, picket them, fill out newspaper coupons? We might let off a little steam that way. But otherwise, it won't do dip. It hasn't in the past, and it won't now.

Can't we do anything to get state lawmakers to behave themselves?

Late last week, as the Albany antics dragged on, I sought answers from several state-government experts: SUNY New Paltz professor Gerald Benjamin; Blair Horner, legislative director of the New York Public Interest Research Group; and Kent Gardner of Rochester's Center for Governmental Research.

Only half facetiously, I asked if we can't just impeach all of the senators. Well, no (though Benjamin suggested that I see what I could find in state law about nonfeasance, the failure to carry out actions they're supposed to). "Both sides can argue that they are attempting to exercise the responsibilities of their office," said Gardner. "I can't imagine that any attempt to impeach would survive in the courts."

We do have the power of the vote, of course. We can just throw the bums out. But we don't vote for state senators until November 2010. Besides, the Democrats and Republicans have rigged the system to essentially guarantee that we'll keep re-electing incumbents. Politicians draw the election-district lines, and they draw those lines to protect themselves.

At some point, the current stalemate will end. The senators will get too embarrassed, or the heat from home will get too bad, or they'll get tired. Or somebody will bribe somebody to change parties. And then the Senate will get back to work. And thoughts of reform will fade back into the fog.

Horner, Gardner, and Benjamin say that we have to keep at it -and that we have to make all state candidates take a reform pledge.

I'm so fed up that I wouldn't trust anybody's pledge. And Gardner worries that we won't stick with this push for reform. "The challenge is that the public doesn't have a lot of patience for change," he says. "I despair of knowing how to deal with a public with such a short attention span."

Good-government groups are talking again about holding a constitutional convention, where, theoretically, we could fix a lot of our problems. But that's a several-year process. And state legislators would insist that they be in control.

Horner, Gardner, and Benjamin say one problem right now is the lack of a strong governor - somebody who, like Nelson Rockefeller, will knock heads, says Horner.

"You should never underestimate the power of the governor of the State of New York," says Gardner. "The governor is an unusually powerful figure" - more powerful than in many states. He can block legislation, and he has unusual power over the budget.

In the current mess, a strong governor "would have been able to co-opt the Senate," says Gardner. "He could have selectively moved some senators around," luring a Republican or two out of the Senate and into the administration.

"It's hardball politics," says Gardner, "but it can be done." Paterson, unfortunately, "is either unwilling or incapable of doing it," says Gardner.

The governor could end Albany's tradition of conducting the state's business behind closed doors with the leaders of the Senate and the Assembly. The governor could refuse to do that and instead meet with the committee chairs. "He can do that tomorrow," says Gardner.

And, says Gardner, the governor could publicly campaign against the legislature on things like member items.

One hope, then, seems to be electing a tough-as-nails governor in 2010 - Republican or Democrat - who will promise reform and who has the clout and the temperament to bring it about. Someone whose campaign theme will be, oh, I don't know, "Day One, Everything Changes"?

But we know what that led to, don't we?

Comments for "URBAN JOURNAL: Are we powerless to fix Albany?" (3)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

User Photo

Chad said on Jul. 09, 2009 at 9:29am

Thanks for your opinion! I dugg this article because I think you have valid points that should be heard internet-wide.

User Photo

R Rapport said on Jul. 10, 2009 at 12:58pm

>Are we powerless to fix Albany<
Can we call for a vote of confidence to the NYS legislature? Is that in the NYS constitution?
If not, can we add it via a referendum?

It seems like it should be about time to have a responsible and responsive legislature.

User Photo

gary said on Jul. 10, 2009 at 7:47pm

I believe this arguement about ren square is to sum it up stupid. Why u ask have u been downtown lately??? downtown should b the focus of small business development, festivals, events, and not to mention a wide spectrum of retail shops. u know so people can stop a bask in our wonderful city instead just parking going into a building for a few hours and then leave for home. The city and the people living in it need to wake up things wont get better if "The People" of Rochester dont speak up for the city especially subject matter that can improve the city. WAKE UP ROCHESTER

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.