Violence has struck again in Rochester. And again. And again.
This year's murder rate isn't as high as last year's, and violent crime is down. But the statistics seem meaningless when we hear reports of yet another shooting and read yet another account of a funeral for a black teenager who was in the wrong place at the wrong time.
In an eloquent statement after some of the most recent killings, Mayor Bob Duffy poured out his frustration. The community, he said, must demand "individual and family accountability" to end the city's culture of violence.
Duffy was particularly passionate in insisting that Rochester police can't stop the violence. "Rochester has almost 150,000 fewer people than at our population peak," he said, "yet we have more police officers than at any time in our history. We cannot put a police officer on every street corner, in every establishment, and in every yard to end violence...."
And he lashed out at "a decrepit street culture that does not value human life or the rights of other citizens."
Duffy is right, of course. These murders - and the shootings and stabbings that could have led to death but didn't - are the actions of people who don't give a whit about the lives of their victims. And this year's violence is not an aberration. It has become a fact of life in certain Rochester neighborhoods.
Rochester police can try to tamp down the violence, with more cops in the target neighborhoods, more searches, more cameras. But they can't prevent it. Prevention will take a massive, community-wide effort.
We'd better aim that effort at the right target, though. And I found part of the mayor's recent statement troubling:
"This is not about poverty," he said. "Poverty does not cause a person to hold a gun to another's head and execute them in cold blood. Poverty does not cause a person to fire a gun into a crowd of young people with no thought to what could happen to an innocent bystander."
Well, of course. People should take responsibility for their actions. Parents should raise their children right. Mayoral sermons won't make that happen, though.
Duffy also insisted that "the community, churches, and families" should support the police and figure out what they can do themselves to reduce violence. But what should they do? There are the easy answers: hold candlelight marches, expand recreational programs for young people, get suburbanites to mentor or tutor students or build Habitat houses.
But that won't address the root of the problem. It will only make us feel like we're doing something.
What will address the root of the problem? Nothing simple, obviously. But it has to start with recognizing the connection between poverty and crime. The mayor's wrong. This is about poverty and its concentration in specific areas of the city.
If there is no connection between poverty and our violence, why is the violence concentrated in the poorest neighborhoods in the region? Why isn't it happening in Pittsford?
If it's not poverty, what is it? Race? I know the mayor doesn't believe that, but many people do, so his statement is a concern.
The mayor's expression of frustration and his call for accountability were important. He has laid out, as few people have, the impossibility of relying on law enforcement to stop violence. He should follow up, though, with an effort to pull together the community - citizens' groups; the educational, business, and medical communities; county government; social service agencies - to come up with a plan that will address the roots and the culture of violence in Rochester.
I had hoped, as I've said before, that the Children's Zone would be that kind of effort. It has floundered. But somebody - the mayor, maybe - has to devise an alternative. Cops can't stop the violence. Neither can sermons about accountability.





Comments for "URBAN JOURNAL: If the cause of violence isn't poverty, what is it?" (5)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.
Robert said on Nov. 10, 2009 at 2:33pm
Mayor Duffy is not claiming that poverty and crime are not correlated, but that poverty does not cause crime. They are interrelated in a much more complex way that also involves many other factors.
Speedmaster said on Nov. 11, 2009 at 5:18pm
Perhaps poverty & crime /are/ correlated, but not in the way presented here? Is it possible that a culture that values crime might lead to poverty?
Rick Meisenzahl said on Nov. 12, 2009 at 12:31am
Because Pittsford has schools and libraries; Rochester does also but Pittsford doesn't waste untold monies on inept school programs, like the city does. Pittsford has families that formulate a socially, respectful attitude towards people and respect for their property. Start making families give a damn about life and property. Start making jail-time an option that you do NOT want to make. There are no fears about consequences.
Lynn said on Dec. 02, 2009 at 1:45pm
Stop blaming poverty. Take a look at the culture of those neighborhoods. Intact families? Rarely. Stable homes? Also rare. Strong adult role models? No way. A desire to achieve? The drop out rate answers that. Teaching values? People who have respect for themselves and others don't do the things we read about and see every day in this City.
And why doesn't this happen in Pittsford? That made me laugh. That statement implies you can buy morals and values. Answer this...how many "no snitching" t-shirts do you see in Pittsford? How many 12 yr olds are shot as they run the streets at midnight?
It's not poverty it's an underclass mentality that exists there. If it's not cool to achieve, want an education, earn respect for concrete achievements then all you have is the current empty, soulless, gimme culture that hangs around street corners looking for quick cash and a free ride.
Forrest said on Jan. 13, 2010 at 10:05pm
What on Earth could be the cause or causes of violence? Lack of respect, lack of compassion, greed of money, etc. etc. There can never be a dramatic "change" in this country unless you get a majority on the same page, all thinking and feeling the same way. I wonder if depression could cause violence? Seems the government wants the entire country to be on anti-depressants. Is the entire country in a depression? Seems everyday prices are rising on basic staple needs. Taxes are skyrocketing. Fuel will never go down enough. Racism seems to never end. The only thing that's not going up is wages. Jobs are disappearing and companys are letting other countries do OUR jobs because of the poor economics here. Seems to be more and more rules, regulations and restrictions placed on our so-called "freedoms" everyday. Vehicles are being made with no thoughts of snow or potholes in mind. They are over-priced hunks of plastic and one wonders why there has to be so many safety devices implemented into them. Used to be able to buy a house for the same price as most vehicles are. What is REALLY meant behind the motto "To Protect and To Serve"? Our politicians are crooks with dirty hands and the country is losing it's faith in the justice system.
So,,,,,good question,
What could be the cause of violence?
DUH !!!
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.