Back to Restaurant Articles

RESTAURANT REVIEW: French Quarter Cafe

The Crescent City in the Flower City

Recommend Article
Total Recommendations (9)

Green beans. My childhood nemesis. My grandmother's recipe required beans cooked with bacon or fatback until they turned dark, almost grey, and nearly dissolved. Even thinking about them now makes me gag just a little bit. Imagine my horror, then, when a dish of very darkly cooked green beans was placed in front of me at the French Quarter Cafe last week. And then try to picture the huge grin that spread across my face when I tasted them - tender without being reduced to goo, full of flavor, seasoned with garlic, salt, maybe a dash of cayenne, and just a bit of red bell pepper for color and an added shot of sweetness. I finished the whole dish and then considered asking for more, but that would have meant leaving behind the sweet potato casserole, or the last bit of Sicilian chicken, or the maque choux, or, heaven forbid, eschewing a cookie to round out the meal.

Only open for six weeks, the French Quarter Cafe on Arnett Boulevard already has the cozy feeling of a neighborhood institution. The warm, friendly dining room has little touches that make it feel just a bit like a tea parlor or your grandmother's living room, and the service is attentive and helpful without feeling intrusive or fussy. The real triumph is the food: simple, honest, straightforward - the sort of food your mother or grandmother would cook if she happened to be from New Orleans.

Self-educated chef-owner Neciah Brown, a Rochester native, offers a wide array of Creole dishes, preserving the rich flavors without the creamy heaviness that often goes hand in hand with Creole food. There are po'boys, etouffee, gumbo, and jambalaya, dirty rice, brabant potatoes, and Natchitoches meat pies. And there are also delicious sides, like Brown's mother's sweet potato casserole, sweet potato fries, and those eye-opening green beans. And then there's the chicken.

It's hard to get me excited about chicken, but I'll make an exception for Brown's Sicilian Chicken ($6.95). Sicily is a long way from New Orleans, but Creole cooking is a melange of the cuisines that found their way to New Orleans over the years, and a sizable number of Sicilian immigrants added their own traditions to the pot. Thus, Sicilian chicken: pieces of chicken pan roasted with garlic, olive oil, rosemary, and white wine. The combination of searing the chicken to lock in the flavors and then finishing it in the oven produces a bird that is perfumed with the garlic and rosemary, meltingly tender, and swimming in a flavorful gravy that begs to be mopped up by the crispy cubes of brabant potato the chicken is served with.

The key to Creole cooking is roux - a mixture of butter and flour cooked over low heat, which is used as the base for any of the classical French sauces you care to name. Creole cooking takes roux to another level, cooking it to a chocolate-brown color just this side of being burned. It's a dangerous game to play with your food, and one of the marks of a good cook is how dark and flavorful he can make his roux. The roux that forms the base of Brown's smoked chicken and sausage gumbo ($3.25 for a cup, $4.75 for a bowl) is a very rich, dark-chocolate brown with a deep nutty flavor that only comes from roux cooked long and slow. The gumbo is thick with pieces of spicy andouille sausage and shreds of tender, buttery-tasting smoked chicken in a broth full of tiny bits of the vegetables that went into the stock. With rice, this could easily have been a meal on its own. As an appetizer it was a wonderful way to open up the palate for good things to come - like Brown's shrimp etouffee.

The roux inBrown's shrimp etouffee ($8.95 for a full portion, $5.50 for a half) is a bit lighter than I would have expected. It thickens a rich red-orange sauce full of red bell pepper, onion, and celery (the "trinity" of Creole cooking), along with a healthy dose of cayenne pepper and a sprinkling of chopped parsley that helps to tie the dish together. The shrimp arrive cooked perfectly, tender and flavorful despite the potential for them to overcook in the piping hot sauce on the way to the table. A generous helping of rice in the middle of the dish allows you to make sure that none of the fragrant, spicy sauce escapes.

There are several very good fried items on the French Quarter Cafe's menu, and all of them are surprisingly light-tasting and delicious. Brabant potatoes ($3), which the menu bills as New Orleans' answer to french fries, are golden brown and crispy outside, fluffy inside and perfectly seasoned. The sweet potato fries ($3) are even better. It's nearly impossible to get sweet potatoes to crisp in the fryer without coating them, and Brown hasn't even tried. Instead, he allows the natural texture of the sweet potato to carry the day, turning out a fry that looks like it was baked and cooked to a point where the natural sweetness of the yam comes out. Seasoned with a bit of salt and a generous dash of cinnamon sugar, these were a favorite on all three of my visits. Similarly, Brown's deep-fried catfish ($7.95) is evidence of his mastery of the medium: the cornmeal crust is thin yet crispy, and so uniform that it creates an envelope in which the flaky white fish steams in its own juices.

The menu offers a bewildering array of sides, but one (in addition to those green beans) is worthy of special mention: Brown's sweet potato casserole ($3) is not Creole, but it is wonderful. The sweet potatoes are mashed and then topped with a crust of pecans, brown sugar, butter, and coconut. Based on a recipe given to him by his mother, the casserole is sweet enough to be a dessert, but has enough substance to stand up as a side dish to the spicy entrees. But just because the casserole is good enough to stand in for dessert, you should not miss out on Norell Brown's cookies.

Virtuosity must run in the Brown family, because his brother Norell makes some of the best cookies I've ever tasted. The buttery, chocolaty goodness of his chewy chocolate fudge cookies was topped in my book only by his chocolate raspberry cookies. The flavor of raspberries balanced with the chocolate in a cookie that was sweet, but not overwhelmingly so. Washed down with a glass of the French Quarter's frankly addictive sweet tea (or, in my case, several glasses), you'd be hard pressed to find a better, or more comforting, conclusion to a meal anywhere in the Flower City.

To find French Quarter Cafe in City Newspaper’s online Restaurant Guide – including a map, user reviews, and more – click here.

French Quarter Cafe

336 Arnett Blvd.

413-0358

Wednesday-Saturday, 11 a.m.-8 p.m.; Sunday 10 a.m.-3 p.m.

Comments for "RESTAURANT REVIEW: French Quarter Cafe" (12)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

User Photo

Joan Hendrick said on Jun. 28, 2008 at 12:01pm

Without a doubt, this is the real deal! Seven of us went to the French Quarter on Friday (6/27) evening for dinner arriving around 5:30 p.m. We were somewhat hesitant because of the two recent write-ups in the newspaper, but were not disappointed. After reading James Leach's review, we wanted to try as much as we could off the menu. Several of the appetizers were not available due to the fact that owner, Neciah Brown, had agreed to do the "Taste of Rochester" hoping to get exposure for his new restaurant, not knowing, of course, about the forthcoming reviews. We tried everything that Mr. Leach wrote about plus a few extras. Everything was top notch. I've been to New Orleans and this is very authentic, fresh and down right tasty. We took along a bottle of wine and some beer which truly enhanced our experience. We can't wait to go back and try the appetizers we missed, along with the cookies that were all shipped off to the festival. Our server, Raquel, informed us that bread pudding, banana pudding and possibly oyster po'boys would be in the works soon. Yummm...

User Photo

griff77 said on Jul. 12, 2008 at 9:03pm

Went for lunch on 7/11. Excellent. Sicilian cheken was a delight. And the cookies left us speechless in awe.

User Photo

Tamika said on Aug. 30, 2008 at 7:13pm

I went today for dinner and was truly pleased. Of course there was sweet tea, which is always good. The Natchitoches were ok, but seemed to lack on the flavor some. Hot sauce made it better. The Brabant potatoes were great. especially for someone who loves french fries like me. The maque choux was good too. The best part of this meal was the fried catfish. I'm a faithful visitor to Unkl Moes for their catfish, but I might have to switch over here. All of this, on top of the nice cozy atmosphere, makes this a gem in the city.

User Photo

Tania said on Jul. 31, 2009 at 7:33pm

Went to the French Quarter Cafe today and it was the best dining I've had in a long time. Having been born and raised in Louisiana, I've been looking for a place that has authentic Cajun and Creole food and it's nice to have finally found one. The decor was charming, the people were super friendly and the food was an absolute dream. Definitely try the chicken and sausage gumbo, which is exactly what I recall my momma making when I was a kid. And the prices were fantastic. I would recommend this place to anyone.

User Photo

Patty said on Dec. 05, 2009 at 9:41pm

One of the best meals ever! Dinner was delicious and the owner went the extra mike to insure our satisfaction. It is my first recommendation when asked "Where's a great place to eat?" All the best at your new location.

User Photo

Ruth Waldron said on Feb. 26, 2010 at 10:21am

My daughter and I enjoyed a wonderful meal at this restaurant last night! It was snowing heavily outside, but inside was inviting, friendly, relaxed, and the food was awesome! The catfish was perfect - not too spicy, perfect crust. The crayfish alfredo, great comfort food - we had several of the side dishes - all tasty - and beignets for dessert, all warm and crusty, sprinkled with powdered sugar. We'll be back! :^)

User Photo

Kate said on Apr. 01, 2010 at 9:24am

French Quarter Cafe has since moved to its new location: 176 S. Goodman Street, near Park Ave.

User Photo

John Fulmer said on Apr. 25, 2010 at 3:20am

Not to be picky, but a roux can be made with any kind of oil--canola, peanut butter, etc--not necessarily butter.

Also, the "The Trinity" includes green bell pepper not red bell pepper.

User Photo

Inez said on Oct. 12, 2010 at 4:26pm

My family and I enjoy my bithday celebration this past weekend at French Quater. Coming froma family of "real Souhern cooks", I was a bit hesitant if evevyone from ages 8-80, would be satisfied. WELL EVERYONE WAS SOOOO better than satisfied and they all LOVED IT!! My mother loved the catfish and stuff chicken wings so much that we will be having them for take out this week. My grandaughter felt like the lil princess from Disney's Princess and the frog as she and the other lil girls are binetes and drank sweet tea. The service was great and very accomodating...allowing us to bring our own birthday cake. Thank you French Quater...we will be back! The art work is amazing!!

User Photo

Teresa said on Oct. 23, 2010 at 9:37pm

Just came from the French Quarter Cafe. Simply put, amazing!
Had the Chicken Half & Half and the Dirty Rice just so I could try more items (everything sounded fantastic). Also tasted the Sweet Potato Casserole, and the Biegnets. Everything was delicious, took me right back to living down south. It's like souped up comfort food. Complex, rich but not heavy, and just spicy enough...
I will definitely be back to try the rest of the items on the menu.

User Photo

Ron Carthen said on Oct. 24, 2010 at 4:56pm

I had my 55 birthday/retirement celebration at the French Quarter Cafe to be shared with 25 guest well Raquel and staff couldn't be more accommodating, we shared a beautiful buffet meal of shimp etouffee and sicilian chicken,green beans,brabant potatoes and peach cobbler the presentation was lovely the atmosphere was warm and inviting the meal was delectable everyone raved over the peach cobbler and I have memories that will last the rest of my life, Thanks again to the chef and Staff at The French Quarter Cafe, God Bless You and Keep, one satisfied Patron

User Photo

Jon Itkin said on Oct. 25, 2010 at 11:24am

This place is absolutely great. Went there for my birthday dinner and we ordered about half the menu. You can't go wrong. Gotta be the best fried catfish around, and the dirty rice is fantastic. Great service too, I swear the server was reading my mind.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.