We hadn't been seated in Monte Alban's spacious dining room for more than a few seconds when our waitress started flirting with my 4-year-old dining companion, complimenting his eyes, cooing at him in Spanish, and generally turning the intractable kid into putty in her hands. Forty minutes later, well fed, watered, and on our way out the door with a mash note to my "lindo baby" in hand, my head was spinning. With the dining room packed and a line forming at the door, how in the world had Monte Alban's staff managed to move us through so quickly without making us feel at all rushed? That takes real talent.
Part of what makes it possible to move huge numbers of people through this very popular Tex-Mex restaurant on Ridge Road is the food. Everything from the beans to the meat is pre-made so that all that a busy cook has to do is assemble whatever combination of tortilla, filling, cheese, and sauce is needed, slide it under the broiler for a few moments, garnish with shredded lettuce and chopped tomato, and send it on its way. All the staples of Tex-Mex food are here: refried beans, Spanish rice, fajitas, ground beef as the default filling in everything, and nacho cheese (available atop quesadillas for 50 cents extra). It's not real Mexican food - for that you need to head east to Sodus, or visit Monterrey Taco at the Public Market on Saturday. But for what it is, Monte Alban is well done and satisfying.
But, as my 4-year-old observed before diving into a virgin mango daiquiri with whipped cream and a cherry ($3.75), "I like this restaurant, but Daddy's not happy." Monte Alban is good, but compared to other Mexican food available close at hand, it doesn't really measure up.
The ingredients are fresh. The chicken and pork are slow roasted to bring out every bit of flavor. The beef used in the fajitas and the chile colorada is a tender and quite flavorful cut of steak. Even the shrimp taste fresh. The avocados, served as both guacamole and as a garnish to some dishes, are perfectly ripe. And the lettuce, even though it is clearly shredded iceberg, is crisp and bright, rather than limp. The refried beans, while they could use a bit of a kick in terms of flavor, are smooth-textured with a good balance of fat to give them a nice round mouth-feel. On the downside, the tomatoes were pink, hard, and inedible. The Spanish rice was similarly disappointing: flavorless, barely pink grains studded with frozen vegetables - cubes of carrot, corn, peas, and green beans.
All meals start with chips and salsa. The chips are fried in-house and liberally salted. The salsa is deep red, smooth, and cold, without much in the way of depth: no appreciable onion or garlic, no fresh herbs, and only the barest hint of heat. The chips, however, give you plenty of time to digest Monte Alban's voluminous menu: five pages long with the first devoted to variations on nachos and salads, the second to 26 different combination plates and fajitas, the third embracing "Especialidades de San Miguel" as well as enchiladas and quesadillas, and the fourth outlining seafood, chicken, pork, and beef platters with a Tex-Mex twist.
A regular-sized cheese dip ($2.95) makes a nice accompaniment to the chips and salsa, and its thin texture and lack of unnatural orange color suggests that it might be made from scratch. Similarly, guacamole ($2.50) had a nice texture and cool flavor, but little or no zip. At our waitress' suggestion we decided to try the chicken mole ($7.50) and the Pancho's special ($9.75), which she assured us is one of the most popular dishes on the menu. Mole, a thick sauce made with a combination of nuts, raisins, guajillo peppers, and unsweetened chocolate, is usually deep brown in color and full of complex flavor. This sauce was red and tasted mostly of tomatoes with just the tiniest hint of any sort of chilis at all. It was quite good, but it wasn't like any mole that I have ever tasted. Pancho's special was equally tasty, but lacked depth: grilled chicken and shrimp topped with a generous handful of cheese and then passed under the broiler.
On another visit, we decided to stick to the traditional staples of the Tex-Mex menu. We ordered a No. 16 combination plate - one chalupa, one chile relleno, and one enchilada served with rice and beans ($7.50) - and a Santarita plate. All three of the selections on the No. 16 came with ground beef filling and were largely indistinguishable from each other. The enchilada tasted very similar to the chile relleno, which would have tasted just like the chalupa had that not been topped with shredded lettuce and tomato. The enchilada was well cooked, the tortilla soft enough to bend easily but not so soft as to collapse under the weight of sauce and cheese. The chile relleno had a nice cornmeal crust and was clearly assembled and fried with great care by the cooks working in the kitchen.
The Santarita plate ($8.99) offered both chile verde and chile colorada on a single plate. This was easily the most successful dish we tried. Large bits of roasted pork were simmered low and slow in a savory green sauce of tomatillos and poblano peppers, along with a fair amount of garlic and crushed red pepper. The meat absorbed the citrus zip and fire of the salsa, and its own fat rounded out the flavors. On the other side of the plate, the chile colorada brought a nice, smoky, and slightly warm bite to chunks of well-cooked steak in a sauce that contained no tomato at all despite its rich red hue. The quesadilla that accompanied the dish was crispy outside and delightfully chewy within, a nice sop for the remaining sauce once you pushed aside the tomatoes.
Monte Alban is not the best Mexican in the area, but it may be the most family-friendly. Tell ‘em "lindo baby" sent you.
Monte Alban
845 E Ridge Rd
697-0615, montealban-mexicangrill.com
Monday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-10 p.m.; Friday-Saturday 11 a.m.-11 p.m.; Sunday noon-9 p.m.





Comments for "RESTAURANT REVIEW: Monte Alban Mexican Grill" (11)
City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.
Karin B said on Nov. 20, 2008 at 9:11am
I am astonded at this article. I have lived in Mexico for a year and traveled there several times before that and Monte Alban is the best Mexican I have had in Rochester, apart from Chilango's and maybe, El Rincon. Further, I am appalled that James Leach claimed this is a Tex-Mex eatery when it most certainly is not. If you want Tex-Mex, go to Salena's and you will find tons of Tex-Mex, liberally salted chip and food that isn't flavored with all those ingredients that makes Mexican food, what I consider, the best food on earth. Give me the opportunity to write a review and I will compliment every tantilizing bite at Monte Alban. Anyone who reads this food review, don't listen to it - try Monte Alban yourself and love every minute!
Steelopus said on Nov. 20, 2008 at 12:09pm
I wholeheartedly agree with Karin B.
I've yet to find a better Mexican restaurant in the area than Monte Alban.
I really don't like when food critics try to compare restaurants to what they deem to be "the competition." Every restaurant will attempt to bring something different to the table, and just because the Mole at Monte Alban didn't match your pre-defined definition of what Mole should be, that doesn't mean you liked it any less.
Judge the food, that's what people are looking for in a review. Did you enjoy your meal? Was it well prepared and did it taste good?
Not only is the food at Monte Alban utterly _delicious_, it's priced very reasonably, much unlike restaurants you'd consider to be competitors, such as Salena's or Los Amigos (Penfield), who's plates are priced too high - with smaller portions and fewer choices.
Tex-Mex? If you want Tex-Mex, go to John's (great), or even a place as uninspiring as Moes (get's the job done). If you want genuine Mexican flavor that is un-Americanized and not designed to fit into the mold, then go to Monte Alban.
Dave said on Nov. 20, 2008 at 1:08pm
Food criitics should be wary of saying what is or isn't "real" ethnic cuisine. What's more "real" American: a hamburger from McDonald's, Don's Original, or 2Vine? To give Monte Alban's food this kind of narrow, is-or-isn't "real" Mexican stamp only betrays a narrow preconception on the part of the reviewer.
marc said on Nov. 20, 2008 at 4:11pm
Interesting. Both are my parents were born in Mexico, different parts. I have many relatives in Mexico, and this is the most authentic place in the area. I have to disagree with this writer. Maybe I'm not Mexican enough to know Mexican food.
Ryan said on Nov. 21, 2008 at 11:52am
All of the previous posts are right on. I have dined many times at Monte Alban, and have yet to be disappointed by anything I have tried, from steak, to chicken to shrimp to the carnitas-the marinated pork-my favorite! The kitchen will even mix up a chelada for you upon request (if you have never had one, its a refreshing beer coctail, try it!). If you like your food spicier, they do offer a homemade hot sauce if you ask for it that WILL add a kick to any meal. Well reviewed commenters!
Kathryn said on Nov. 24, 2008 at 10:34am
My husband and I ate at Monte Alban this past Friday night - we cleaned our plates (it was really good) but I have to say that nothing beats El Rincon (Sodus) and Rio Tomatlan (new name, was El Rincon Mexicano Dos in Canandaigua) - for authentic Mexican food.
Autumn said on Nov. 25, 2008 at 3:07pm
I agree with the above posters. I've traveled to Mexico several times and this definitely compares to what I've had at the out of the way restaurants and cafes I've been to. The food is excellent, and easily the best Mexican in Rochester. Just because a place is not pretentious or expensive doesn't mean it can't be superb.
Tex said on Nov. 26, 2008 at 10:10am
I'm from West Texas, and after living here for the past 12 years, have yet to find any place in the region that compares what I consider home cooking. Until we found the Monte Alban, that is. The waitstaff is always friendly and courteous and we've enjoyed every meal ordered from the extensive menu. We've tried the competition. Monte Alban is the best.
Anime said on Nov. 28, 2008 at 11:31pm
Yes Tex I agree with you. It was difficult to choose from such an extensive menu at Monte Alban. I still feel the water in my mouth, the moment I think of Monte!!
Peter
Alex said on Jan. 10, 2009 at 12:22pm
I've been to Mexico. I've been to Monte Alban. I've also met James Leach. Monte Alban is, by far, the most authentic Mexican restaurant in the area (although, the local competition isn't much by comparison).
Foodie said on Sep. 26, 2009 at 11:53pm
I AGREE with the previous posts! This is great mexican food! In Rochester it's so hard to find anything but Amercian style food. We don't need any more Ruby Tuesdays, Fridays, Applebees.... need I say more! Ughhhh! WE LOVE Monte Alban! I've always had good service and the wait staff is so friendly. And the Margaritas are great too! Yummy, I'm making myself hungry!
Leave A Comment
Respond on Your Blog
Create an Account
or
Login
If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.