Pin It

Best of Rochester 2013: Food & Drink 

Best Pizza Mark's Pizzeria. Many area locations. (Runners up: Pontillos | Salvatores | Pizza Stop)

Best Gourmet Burger Gate House. 274 N. Goodman St., 473-2090, (Runners up: Brick 'n' Motor | Frog Pond | Good Luck | Tap & Table)

Best Barbecue Dinosaur Bar-B-Que. 99 Court St., 325-7090, (Runners up: Beale Street | Good Smoke | Sticky Lips)

Best Wings Jeremiah's Tavern. 1104 Monroe Ave, 461-1313; 2200 Buffalo Road, Gates, 247-0022; (Runners up: Distillery | Pontillo's | Dinosaur)

Best Fish Fry The Old Toad. 277 Alexander St., 232-2626, (Runners up: Bill Gray's | Captain Jim's | Davies Sea Food)

Best "Plate" Nick Tahou's. 320 W. Main St., 436-0184; 3070 W. Henrietta Rd., Henrietta, 272-1182; (Runners up: Dogtown | Empire Hots | Mark's Texas Hots)

Best Breakfast Jines. 658 Park Ave., 461-1280, (Runners up: Frog Pond | Highland Park Diner | James Brown's Place)

Best Bagel Balsam Bagels. 288 N. Winton Rd, 482-5080, (Runners up: Bagel Land | Brownstein's Deli & Bakery | Soho Bagel Café)

Best Cookies Savoia Pastry Shoppe. 2267 Clifford Ave., 482-1130, (Runners up: Classy Cookie & Deli | Gruttadauria Bakery | Leo's Bakery & Deli | Orange Glory)

Best Ice Cream/Frozen Custard/Frozen Yogurt Abbott's Frozen Custard. Many area locations. (Runners up: Hedonist Artisan Ice Cream | Lugia's | Pittsford Farms Diary)

Best Food Truck Le Petit Poutine. @lepetitpoutine. (Runners up: Brick-N-Motor | Lettuce B. Frank | Marty's Meats)

Best Asian Restaurant The King & I. 1455 E. Henrietta Road, 427-8090, (Runners up: Chen Garden | Flavors of Asia | Mamasan's)

Best Mexican Restaurant Salena's. 302 N. Goodman St. #247, 256-5980, (Runners up: John's Tex-Mex | La Casa | Monte Alban)

Best Italian Restaurant Mario's. 2740 Monroe Ave., Pittsford, 271-1111, (Runners up: Guido's Pasta Villa | Ristorante Lucano | Rocco)

Best Indian Restaurant India House. 998 S. Clinton Ave., 461-0880, (Runners up: Amaya Bar and Grill | Tandoor of India | Thali of India)

Best Mediterranean Restaurant Aladdin's. Many area locations. (Runners up: Olives Greek Taverna | Sinbad's | Voula's Greek Sweets)

Best Sushi California Rollin'. Many area locations. (Runners up: Banzai | Plum House | Shiki)

Best Vegetarian/Vegan Restaurant Owl House. 75 Marshall St., 360-2920, (Runners up: Aladdin's | Natural Oasis | Voula's Greek Sweets)

Best Gluten-Free Options Owl House. 75 Marshall St., 360-2920, (Runners up: Ellie's Gluten-Free Bakery | Harry G's | Natural Oasis)

Best Restaurant for Delivery Mark's Pizzeria. Many area locations. (Runners up: Chen Garden | Salvatore's | Sol Burrito)

Best Buffet Mario's. 2740 Monroe Ave., Pittsford, 271-1111, (Runners up: China Buffet (Jefferson Road) | Espada | Thali of India)

Best Specialty Food Shop Lori's Natural Foods. 900 Jefferson Road, Henrietta, 424-2323, (Runners up: Hedonist Artisan Chocolate | Little Bleu Cheese Shop | Mise en Place)

Best Coffee Shop Java's Cafe. 16 Gibbs St., 232-4820, (Runners up: Boulder Coffee Co. | Joe Bean Coffee | Starry Nites)

Best Barista Frankie Katsampas (Java's) 16 Gibbs St., 232-4820, (Runners up: Krystyna Buckhout (Dark Horse) | Tony Colon (Fuego) | Meredith Feary (Starry Nites))

Best Outdoor Dining Pomodoro. 3400 Monroe Ave., 586-7000, (Runners up: Jines | Pelican's Nest | Tap & Table)

Best Cheap Eats Dogtown. 691 Monroe Ave., 271-6620, (Runners up: Aladdin's | Harry G's | John's Tex Mex)

Best Upscale Eatery Good Luck. 50 Anderson Ave., 340-6161, (Runners up: 2Vine | Black & Blue | Lento)

Best New Restaurant TRATA. 145 Culver Road, 270-5460, (Runners up: Avvino | La Casa | The Revelry)

In This Guide...

  • Best of Rochester 2013

    Here's the deal
    Normally I start out the introduction to City Newspaper's annual Best of Rochester issue by blathering about the awesomeness of Rochester and making terrible puns based around that year's theme. I'm taking a different tactic this year — although there will probably still be puns.

  • Best of Rochester 2013: Goods & Services

    New Retail Store Little Bleu Cheese Shop. 684 South Ave., 730-8296,

  • Best of Rochester 2013: Local Color

    Best Local Politician Louise Slaughter. @louiseslaughter (Runners up: Lisa Jacques | Tom Richards | Joe Robach)

  • Best of Rochester 2013: Arts & Entertainment

    Best Local Band Something Else (Runners up: Bogs Visionary Orchestra | Cherry Bomb | Sirens & Sailors) Best Solo Musician Mikaela Davis (Runners up: Johnny Bauer | Hieronymus Bogs | Ted Nicolosi)

  • Best of Rochester 2013: Nightlife

    Best New Bar TRATA. 145 Culver Rd., 270-5460,

  • Best of Rochester 2013: CITY Critic Picks

    Best Way to Fool Others Into Thinking You Cooked From Scratch Newbury Park Pastries' Chicken Pot Pie

  • Best of Rochester 2013: Best Answers

    Off-the-cuff, sometime off-color responses to our Best of Rochester 2013 Primary Ballot
    Spelling bee "La Petite Pouting"; "La Petite Pouring"; "Pouting Truck"; "Me Petite Poutine"; "Poutite Poutine"; "Poutine: Have fun sorting through all of the spellings of that" (Best Food Truck)

Latest in Best of Rochester

More by City Newspaper Readers

Browse Listings

Submit an event
Good City Soil Project @ 540WMain

Good City Soil Project @ 540WMain

540WestMain is partnering with Green Collar Collaborations for the pilot event of...
Screening & Discussion: "July '64" @ Livestream

Screening & Discussion: "July '64" @ Livestream

Presented by Citizen Action of NY, Rochester Chapter. Registration required....
Pirates & Mermaids @ Virtual Strong National Museum of Play

Pirates & Mermaids @ Virtual Strong National Museum of Play

RSVP to the museum's Facebook event page for DIY activities, sing-alongs, and...

View all of today's events »

Tweets @RocCityNews

© 2020 City Newspaper.

Website powered by Foundation.