Pin It

Many city teachers not up to par, says new report 

Student behavior and disciplinary issues are not the main reasons so many Rochester public schools are failing; ineffective teachers and problems with developing the curriculum are. And only 30 percent of poorly performing schools are functioning well enough to make the improvements they need to make.

Those were some of the conclusions that a group of educational consultants, most of them former superintendents, reached after assessing Rochester schools.

The consultants' findings were presented at the Rochester school board's Excellence in Student Achievement Committee meeting yesterday. District officials hired the consultants to examine Rochester's "priority" and "focus" schools: those that are performing in the lowest 5 percent statewide or are showing signs of reaching that level. More than half of the city's schools fit the criteria.

The consultants were asked to both diagnose problems in the schools and provide corrective recommendations to get removed from the state's "priority" and "focus" designations. The consultants spent 3000 hours observing classrooms in 49 Rochester schools. They assessed six areas: leadership capacity, school leader practices and decisions, curriculum development and support, teacher practices and support, student social and emotional health, and family and community engagement.

The major finding was the need for teacher improvement, Dan Lowengard, the former superintendent of Utica and Syracuse schools, said. Students were not engaged, he said.

"We didn't see discipline in the classrooms as a major problem," he said.

Too many teachers are isolated in their classrooms rather than working in collaboration with stronger, more effective teachers, Lowengard said. While many district teachers are exceptional, he said, many others needed professional development. And many of the teachers who most need the professional development choose not to pursue it, he said.

The critique drew sharp criticism from Adam Urbanski, president of the Rochester Teachers Association.

"This is more of the fix-the-teachers narrative, and it implied that teachers are not accountable, when they're the most accountable people in this whole mix," Urbanski said in a phone interview earlier today.

The consultants said nothing about the district's problems with spotty student attendance, management issues at both central office and in the schools, or the ravages of concentrated poverty, Urbanski said.

"Their conclusion about student discipline would make most teachers in Rochester question what planet they're from," Urbanski said.

Some board members were also skeptical of the report's findings. Board president Van White said he was concerned that the report was too complicated to be useful. And he said that district's problems are not limited to teacher effectiveness.

Caterina Leone-Mannino, the Rochester district's executive director of school innovation, said the report's recommendations would be used to develop a plan for school improvement in each of the low-performing schools. And the plans, which have in the past been written to comply with the state's mandates, will be more of an interactive document used daily to measure progress and implement changes as needed.

In the past, such plans "sat on a shelf and collected dust," she said. "This is a shift for us."

Speaking of...

Comments (14)

Showing 1-14 of 14

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-14 of 14

Add a comment

Browse Listings

Submit an event

"The Wild Pear Tree" (2018) @ Dryden Theatre

Flapjack Saturday Community Fundraiser @ First Baptist Church of Penfield

Flapjack Saturday Community Fundraiser @ First Baptist Church of Penfield

Proceeds support Resolve, dedicated to preventing domestic and sexual violence against women....

Annual Film Festival & Community Discussion on Race: Racism & the Power of Words on Communities of Color @ Spiritus Christi Church

The half-day event will include watching several film clips followed by small...

View all of today's events »

  • Re: County exec race will be Dinolfo versus Bello

    • Bello was Irondequoit supervisor for two years and two and 1/2 months, Jan. 1, 2016…

    • on February 15, 2019
  • Re: County exec race will be Dinolfo versus Bello

    • So, Happy, it sounds like you agree with me. There's nothing new and exciting in…

    • on February 15, 2019
  • Re: Diner series: Mt. Hope Diner

    • I have been going here for at least 50 years, back in the Pat and…

    • on February 15, 2019
  • More »
  • This Week's Issue

    Cover Story:
    Education... means emancipation
    What would Frederick Douglass think now of the state of education in the city he loved? Seven Rochesterians – community leaders, students, and parents – offer their assessment and their advice.
    read more ...

    Tweets @RocCityNews

    © 2019 City Newspaper.

    Website powered by Foundation.